Skip to main content

Trench Collapse

Trench and excavation collapses can cause suffocation, crush injuries, and death.

The short answer

A trench collapse happens when soil or rock breaks from an excavation wall and falls or slides onto a worker. Water, vibration, nearby loads, and missing or inadequate protective systems can contribute to a cave-in.

The Fatal Reality of Trench Collapses

Trench work is one of the most dangerous activities in construction. These statistics from OSHA highlight the scope of the problem.

39→15→12
Deaths declining (2022-2024)

Per OSHA, trench collapse fatalities dropped nearly 70%: from 39 deaths in 2022 to 15 in 2023 to 12 in 2024, following enhanced enforcement.

3,000 lbs
Per cubic yard

According to OSHA, a cubic yard of soil can weigh as much as 3,000 pounds—equal to a compact car.

70%
Decline since 2022

OSHA reports trench fatalities have declined nearly 70% since 2022 due to intensive enforcement and outreach.

100%
Preventable

OSHA considers virtually all trench collapses preventable with proper shoring, shielding, or sloping.

What Is a Trench Collapse?

A trench collapse occurs when the walls of an excavated trench cave in, burying or crushing workers inside. Trenches are narrow excavations where the depth exceeds the width, commonly dug for utilities, foundations, and underground infrastructure.

Trench collapses happen with devastating speed and force:

Cave-ins and wall failures are the most common type: - Entire trench walls collapse inward - Partial wall sections break away - Soil slides down from trench edges - Undermined walls suddenly give way - Water-saturated soil flows into trench

Spoil pile slides occur when excavated soil falls back in: - Spoil piled too close to trench edge - Equipment or materials at trench edge - Vibration from nearby equipment - Soil shifting or settling

Undermining and washouts weaken trench walls: - Groundwater seeping through walls - Nearby excavation undermining soil - Broken pipes flooding trenches - Rain accumulating in trenches

Secondary collapse after initial cave-in: - Rescue attempts triggering additional collapse - Weakened walls continuing to fail - Adjacent areas becoming unstable - Equipment causing further collapse

The physics of trench collapse are terrifying: one cubic yard of soil weighs approximately 2,700 pounds. A worker buried to the waist may be held by 1,000+ pounds of soil—making self-rescue impossible and creating extreme pressure on the body.

Common Causes of Trench Collapses

Trench collapses are entirely preventable. Every collapse represents a failure of safety systems that should have been in place.

No Protective System

The most common failure—working with no protection:

  • Working in unshored trenches
  • No trench box or shield used
  • Sloping not provided
  • Benching not implemented
  • Assuming "quick work" doesn't need protection

Inadequate Protection

Protection present but insufficient:

  • Shoring not properly installed
  • Trench boxes too small for excavation
  • Shields not extending above surface
  • Inadequate sloping angles
  • Systems not adjusted as conditions change

Soil Conditions Ignored

Failure to assess and address soil type:

  • Treating all soil as stable (Type A)
  • Not testing soil classification
  • Ignoring water in soil
  • Not adjusting for previously disturbed soil
  • Failing to recognize unstable conditions

Spoil Pile Violations

Excavated soil creating hazards:

  • Spoil piled within 2 feet of edge (violation)
  • Heavy equipment at trench edge
  • Materials stored too close to edge
  • Vibration from nearby operations
  • Surface loads not considered

Water Accumulation

Water dramatically weakens soil:

  • Groundwater seeping into trench
  • Rain accumulating in excavation
  • Broken pipes or water lines
  • No dewatering system in use
  • Drainage inadequate

Changing Conditions

Failure to adapt to changes:

  • Weather changes after excavation
  • Freezing and thawing cycles
  • Nearby construction affecting stability
  • Traffic vibration near trenches
  • Extended open excavation periods

Supervision Failures

Management contributing to collapses:

  • No competent person on site
  • No daily inspections performed
  • Production pressure overriding safety
  • Ignoring worker safety concerns
  • Failure to stop work when unsafe

Need help understanding your case?

Free, confidential consultation—no obligation.

Free Case Review

Injuries from Trench Collapses

Trench collapse injuries are among the most severe in construction. The weight and pressure of soil creates crushing forces that the human body cannot withstand.

Fatalities

Trench collapses have an extremely high death rate: - Workers fully buried rarely survive - Suffocation occurs within minutes - Crushing injuries are immediately fatal - Rescue often takes too long - Even partial burial can be fatal

Traumatic Asphyxiation

The weight of soil causes suffocation: - Chest compression prevents breathing - Pressure prevents rib expansion - Suffocation in 3-5 minutes - Can occur even with head above soil - Rescue must be immediate

Crush Syndrome

Prolonged compression causes systemic damage: - Muscle tissue breakdown (rhabdomyolysis) - Kidney failure from released proteins - Heart failure from potassium release - Can be fatal even after rescue - Requires immediate medical intervention

Spinal Cord Injuries

Impact and compression damage the spine: - Vertebral fractures from impact - Spinal cord compression - Paraplegia or quadriplegia - Complete or incomplete paralysis - Permanent disability common

Multiple Fractures

The weight of soil breaks bones: - Pelvic fractures (extremely serious) - Multiple rib fractures - Leg and hip fractures - Spinal fractures - Internal organ damage from broken ribs

Internal Injuries

Crushing pressure damages organs: - Liver and spleen rupture - Internal bleeding - Lung collapse - Kidney damage - Bowel and bladder injury

Traumatic Brain Injury

Head trauma from collapse: - Skull fractures - Concussions - Intracranial bleeding - Hypoxic brain damage - Cognitive impairment

Long-Term Consequences

Survivors of trench collapses face: - Permanent disability - Chronic kidney problems - Multiple reconstructive surgeries - Ongoing rehabilitation - Post-traumatic stress disorder - Complete loss of independence - Financial devastation

What Compensation Can You Recover?

A trench collapse claim may address medical costs, lost wages and earning capacity, and pain and suffering, depending on the facts and available legal claim.

Medical Expenses

Medical costs may include: - Emergency trauma care and surgery - Extended ICU and hospital stays - Dialysis for kidney failure - Spinal cord injury treatment - Brain injury rehabilitation - Long-term physical therapy - Future medical expenses - Home care and nursing - Medical equipment

Lost Wages and Earning Capacity

Lost income and earning capacity may include: - All lost wages during recovery - Lost overtime and benefits - Permanent disability payments - Total loss of earning capacity - Vocational rehabilitation costs - Lost retirement contributions

Pain and Suffering

Pain and suffering may include: - Physical pain and trauma - Emotional distress - Terror of being buried - PTSD and psychological harm - Loss of enjoyment of life - Permanent disability impact - Loss of consortium

Wrongful Death Damages

When collapse causes death: - Loss of financial support - Funeral and burial expenses - New York wrongful-death damages are generally limited to pecuniary losses. - Loss of parental guidance - Pre-death pain and suffering - Punitive damages where warranted

There is no typical value for these cases. What a claim may be worth depends on the injury, the evidence, the available insurance and the venue, and results in other cases do not predict the outcome of yours.

Need help understanding your case?

Free, confidential consultation—no obligation.

Free Case Review

What to Do After a Trench Collapse

Trench collapses are emergencies requiring immediate response. For survivors and families, the following steps are critical.

1. Emergency Response

Trench collapses require specialized rescue: - Call 911 immediately - Do not enter the trench—rescuers become victims - Cave-ins often continue after initial collapse - Confined space rescue teams required - Keep area clear for emergency response - Mark utility locations for rescuers

2. Medical Treatment

Survivors need immediate medical care: - Crush syndrome can be fatal even after rescue - Kidney function must be monitored - Spinal injuries require immobilization - Accept all recommended treatment - Document all injuries and symptoms

3. Preserve Evidence

Evidence in trench cases is critical: - Photograph the site before it changes - Document soil conditions visible - Note presence or absence of shoring/shielding - Identify spoil pile location - Record weather and water conditions - Get witness names and contacts - Preserve any safety documents

4. Report to OSHA

OSHA must be notified: - Fatalities must be reported within 8 hours - Hospitalizations within 24 hours - OSHA investigation will document violations - Investigation reports become evidence - Employer cannot interfere with investigation

5. Contact an Attorney Immediately

Trench collapse cases require prompt legal action: - Evidence can be lost quickly - Site conditions change rapidly - Expert analysis often needed - Multiple defendants may be liable - OSHA investigation should be monitored

6. For Families (Wrongful Death)

If a loved one died: - Do not sign anything without legal advice - Preserve all work records - Document relationship to deceased - Keep all funeral expense records - Wrongful death claims have deadlines

Required Trench Safety Measures

Understanding proper trench safety helps identify the violations that caused your injury.

OSHA Requirements

OSHA requires protection in trenches 5 feet or deeper:

  • Sloping: Cutting back trench walls at angles
  • Shoring: Installing supports to prevent cave-in
  • Shielding: Using trench boxes to protect workers
  • Benching: Creating steps in trench walls

All trenches 20 feet or deeper require engineered systems.

Soil Classification

Soil type determines protection requirements:

  • Type A: Cohesive soils, unconfined compressive strength of 1.5 tsf or greater
  • Type B: Cohesive soils with strength between 0.5 and 1.5 tsf
  • Type C: Cohesive soils with strength less than 0.5 tsf, granular soils

Type C soil requires the most aggressive protection. Previously disturbed soil is never Type A.

Competent Person Requirement

OSHA requires a competent person who:

  • Can identify existing and predictable hazards
  • Has authority to take corrective measures
  • Inspects trenches daily and after changes
  • Classifies soil properly
  • Ensures protective systems are adequate

Spoil Distance

Excavated materials must be kept at least 2 feet from trench edge. This prevents:

  • Material falling back into trench
  • Edge loading causing collapse
  • Reduced visibility of trench edge
  • Tripping hazards near excavation

Access and Egress

Workers must have means of escape: - Ladders, stairs, or ramps required - No more than 25 feet of travel to exit - Access cannot be blocked - Must be maintained during work

When these measures are absent, property owners and contractors are liable under New York law.

OSHA's Role in Trench Collapse Cases

OSHA investigations play a significant role in trench collapse claims.

OSHA Investigation Process

After a serious trench incident: - Investigators arrive at the scene - Soil samples may be taken - Witness interviews conducted - Photos and measurements documented - Protective systems evaluated - Citations issued for violations

Citations as Evidence

OSHA citations support legal claims:

  • Document specific safety violations
  • Establish regulatory standards breached
  • Show employer knowledge of requirements
  • Create record of safety failures
  • Can be used in civil litigation

Common OSHA Citations in Trench Cases

Typical violations found: - No protective system (29 CFR 1926.652) - Spoil pile too close to edge (29 CFR 1926.651) - No competent person (29 CFR 1926.651) - Inadequate access/egress (29 CFR 1926.651) - No soil classification performed

Penalties for Violations

OSHA penalties include: - Willful violations: up to $156,259 per violation - Serious violations: up to $15,625 per violation - Criminal prosecution for willful deaths - Repeat violations multiplied

Coordination with Legal Action

Your attorney can: - Obtain OSHA investigation files - Use citations to prove violations - Coordinate with OSHA investigators - Subpoena OSHA documents - Cite Industrial Code violations

OSHA documentation often provides powerful evidence of the safety failures that caused your injury.

Trench Collapses Across New York

Trench collapses occur throughout New York State wherever excavation work takes place—utility installation, foundation work, and infrastructure projects create daily trench hazards for thousands of workers.

New York City Boroughs

Manhattan sees significant trench work despite its dense development. Utility repairs, subway construction, and new development require excavation in challenging urban conditions. The island's bedrock can create false confidence—even shallow trenches in disturbed soil above rock collapse without warning.

Brooklyn has experienced trench accidents during the borough's construction boom. New residential developments, aging infrastructure repairs, and utility upgrades all require excavation. The borough's varied soil conditions—from sandy areas near the coast to clay inland—demand different protective approaches.

Queens presents diverse trench hazards across its expansive territory. Infrastructure projects, residential development, and commercial construction require constant excavation work. The borough's size means trenching occurs in soil conditions ranging from marsh-adjacent areas to stable upland sites.

The Bronx sees trench work for infrastructure improvements and new development. The borough's revitalization has increased excavation activity. Hilly terrain creates additional challenges when slopes adjoin trench locations.

Staten Island experiences trench work primarily for residential utility installation and infrastructure improvements. Lower density means more underground utility connections. The borough's varied topography requires careful soil assessment.

Upstate Infrastructure

Buffalo and Rochester have extensive underground infrastructure requiring constant maintenance and replacement. Aging water and sewer systems, harsh winter conditions that damage pipes, and new development create ongoing trench work. Freeze-thaw cycles can destabilize soil around existing trenches.

Syracuse and Albany present similar challenges with aging infrastructure and active construction. Government building projects, university expansion, and healthcare facility construction all involve excavation work with trench hazards.

Suburban Westchester

The urban centers of Yonkers and White Plains see trench work for new development and infrastructure upgrades. High-rise construction requires deep excavation for foundations. Utility work for growing populations creates additional trench exposure.

Throughout New York, Labor Law 240 and 241 provide powerful protections for trench collapse victims. The location doesn't change your rights—whether in Manhattan or Buffalo, property owners and contractors must provide proper trench protection.

Related Accident Types

If you've been injured in a trench collapse, you may also want to learn about related construction accidents:

Common Causes

Trenches 5 feet or deeper...

Trenches 5 feet or deeper require protection

One cubic yard of soil...

One cubic yard of soil weighs 3,000+ pounds

Cave-ins can happen without warning...

Cave-ins can happen without warning

Rescue after burial is often...

Rescue after burial is often unsuccessful

Common Safety Violations

No shoring or shielding installed

Improper sloping of trench walls

Excavated material too close to edge

No trench box used

Working in unprotected trench

No competent person on site

Frequently Asked Questions About Trench Collapse

Get answers to the most common questions about trench collapse claims and your rights under Labor Law 240.

What compensation can I get for a trench collapse?

Compensation may include medical costs, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other losses. There is no typical value for these cases. What a claim may be worth depends on the injury, the evidence, the available insurance and the venue, and results in other cases do not predict the outcome of yours.

How does Labor Law 240 apply to trench collapse?

Labor Law 240 does not automatically apply to a trench cave-in. It requires a qualifying elevation hazard, a statutory safety-device violation, and proof that the violation proximately caused the injury. Trench collapse claims more often turn on Labor Law 241(6) and a specific applicable Industrial Code rule, such as 12 NYCRR 23-4.2. A lawyer can assess the excavation, the protective system, and how the injury occurred to identify the available claims.

How long do I have to file a claim?

In New York, you generally have 3 years to file a personal injury lawsuit, but acting quickly preserves evidence and strengthens your case.

What if I was partially at fault?

Whether a worker's conduct affects a Labor Law 240 claim depends on the facts. Defenses can include sole proximate cause or a recalcitrant worker, and owners of one- or two-family dwellings who do not direct the work may be exempt.

Do I need a lawyer?

A case review can help explain possible claims, deadlines, and next steps. Tell us what happened and get a free, confidential case review.

What is a trench collapse, and how does one happen?

A trench collapse, or cave-in, occurs when soil or rock separates from the side of an excavation and suddenly moves into it, trapping, burying, or injuring someone. Water, vibration, nearby heavy equipment, spoil piles, and changes in soil can make walls unstable. A wall can fail even if the trench looks firm from above. OSHA defines a cave-in in 29 CFR 1926.650 and requires employees to be protected by an adequate system under 29 CFR 1926.652, unless a stated exception applies. A competent person must inspect excavations and protective systems as required by 29 CFR 1926.651(k).

Can a partial trench burial be life-threatening?

Yes. Soil around the chest can restrict breathing even when a worker's head remains above ground. A partial cave-in can also cause crush injuries or leave the worker trapped while the excavation remains unstable. Do not enter an unsafe trench to attempt an unplanned rescue; call emergency services. OSHA requires protection from cave-ins under 29 CFR 1926.652 and inspection by a competent person under 29 CFR 1926.651(k). These rules matter because a second collapse can endanger both the trapped worker and rescuers. Immediate medical assessment is important after any entrapment.

What trench protection is required before workers enter?

Under 29 CFR 1926.652(a)(1), employees in an excavation need an adequate protective system against cave-ins unless the excavation is entirely in stable rock or is less than five feet deep and a competent person finds no indication of a potential cave-in. Protective methods include sloping, shoring, and shielding when properly designed and used. A competent person must inspect daily and as conditions change under 29 CFR 1926.651(k). New York's 12 NYCRR 23-4.2 also sets trench requirements, including sheeting and shoring for qualifying excavations. Depth alone does not settle every safety or liability question.

What compensation can a trench collapse injury claim cover?

Depending on the claim and proof, compensation may address medical costs, lost wages, reduced earning capacity, and pain and suffering. A worker with serious injuries may also need to document future treatment and limits on returning to work. There is no typical value for a trench collapse claim, and compensation for one specific case cannot be predicted. Workers' compensation benefits and a possible claim against a covered third party are separate issues that may interact. Keep medical records, work records, and any safe-to-obtain evidence about the excavation and protective system for a licensed New York attorney to review.

Does Labor Law 240 automatically apply to a trench cave-in?

No. A cave-in does not automatically establish a Labor Law 240 claim. Section 240 requires a qualifying elevation hazard, a violation involving a required safety device, and proof that the violation proximately caused the injury. Trench claims more often turn on Labor Law 241(6) and an applicable, specific Industrial Code rule, such as a requirement in 12 NYCRR 23-4. OSHA's excavation rules, including 29 CFR 1926.651 and 1926.652, also address safe work practices. The excavation's dimensions, protective system, work being performed, and cause of injury determine which legal theories warrant review.

How New York Labor Law Applies to a Trench collapse

The medical profile is asphyxia and crush, not impact — and §241(6), not §240(1), is the dominant theory.

A trench cave-in is the opposite of a fall case. Conventional doctrine holds that laterally collapsing earth is not a §240(1) "falling object," so the dominant theory is Labor Law §241(6) — through the Industrial Code's excavation subpart — and §200, which turns on the general contractor's actual control or notice. Whether §240(1) ever reaches a cave-in is fact-dependent and unsettled, so it is reviewed case by case rather than assumed. A §241(6) claim requires a violation of a specific, applicable Industrial Code provision that amounted to negligence and proximately caused the injury; the duty is non-delegable, and comparative negligence can reduce the recovery. An OSHA violation is evidence of negligence, not a §241(6) predicate.

In Mann v. Mezuyon, LLC (2026 NY Slip Op 03257), the Court of Appeals held that the Industrial Code's "struck or endangered by excavation equipment" provision is not specific enough to support §241(6), so the claim anchors instead on the sheeting-and-shoring provisions.

NY Industrial Code (12 NYCRR Part 23)

NY Industrial Code Subpart 23-4 (Excavations) supplies the §241(6) predicates — most importantly the requirement that a trench 5 feet deep or more with sides steeper than the code's table be sheeted and shored. After Mann v. Mezuyon, LLC (2026), do not lead on the excavation-equipment provision; anchor on the sheeting-and-shoring requirements.

Federal OSHA Standards That Govern Trench Collapse

These are the verbatim federal standards enforceable on every New York construction site. An OSHA citation for a standard that proximately caused your injury supports a Labor Law \u00a7241(6) claim independent of Labor Law \u00a7240.

29 CFR 1926.652(a)(1)

An adequate cave-in protective system is required, except in stable rock or in an excavation under 5 feet deep where a competent person finds no indication of a potential cave-in.

29 CFR 1926.651 (egress)

A means of egress within 25 feet of lateral travel in trenches 4 feet deep or more.

29 CFR 1926.651 (inspections)

Daily competent-person inspection for possible cave-ins before work starts, as needed during the shift, and after rainstorms or other hazard-increasing events.

How a Trench Collapse Happens \u2014 and the Injuries It Causes

The Mechanism

Lethality is by mass, not height: soil is heavy enough to crush and suffocate a worker. A wall collapses inward from a missing protective system, an undercut bank, vibration, rain, or spoil piled too close to the edge.

The Medical Reality

Mechanical or compressive asphyxia is the cause of death — the chest cannot expand even with a clear airway. Crush syndrome (rhabdomyolysis leading to hyperkalemia and acute renal failure) means a worker can be extricated alive and conscious and then die hours later. Compartment syndrome, thoracic crush, and suffocation follow. Even brief, partial burial is potentially fatal.

What Drives Case Value in a Trench Collapse Claim

Damages can include medical expenses, lost earnings and earning capacity, and pain and suffering; in a fatal case, the family's financial losses. There is no typical number. A missing protective system is central liability evidence.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

What the Defense Will Argue

Argue the soil conditions were unpredictable, lean on a daily-inspection record to show a competent person checked the trench, and strategically try to knock out any §240(1) theory so that comparative fault becomes available under §241(6) and §200.

The New York Cases That Control a Trench Collapse Claim

Misicki v. Caradonna, 12 NY3d 511 (2009)

A §241(6) claim must rest on a concrete, specific Industrial Code command, not a general standard.

Rizzuto v. L.A. Wenger Contracting, 91 NY2d 343 (1998)

§241(6) liability is non-delegable and attaches without proof the owner supervised the work, but it requires a violation of a specific Industrial Code provision that amounts to negligence and proximately caused the injury; comparative negligence applies.

More Questions About Trench Collapse Claims

A trench collapsed on a coworker — how is that case different from a fall?

Very different. A cave-in is governed primarily by Labor Law §241(6) and the excavation safety code, not the Scaffold Law, and the injury is crush and asphyxia rather than impact trauma. A missing or inadequate protective system is central evidence in the civil case.

The trench wasn't that deep — does the 5-foot rule still help?

It can. Federal law requires a cave-in protective system unless the excavation is in stable rock or under 5 feet deep with no indication of a potential cave-in, and New York's excavation code requires sheeting and shoring for trenches 5 feet or deeper with steep sides; in some soils it also requires side protection between 3 and 5 feet unless stability is certified in writing. Even shallow or brief burials can be fatal because of the weight of the soil.

12 “Excavation or soil work” incidents citywide, Sep 2025 – Aug 2026

NYC Department of Buildings recorded 12 incidents in this category across the five boroughs in the last 12 complete months, with 4 workers injured and 1 killed. See the monthly numbers by borough and incident type.

How a Trench Collapse Actually Causes Harm

The mechanism matters in litigation. Defense counsel will argue the worker caused his own injury. The biomechanics of how this accident type produces specific injuries — and which OSHA standard was supposed to prevent it — is what proves the violation caused the harm.

Unsupported wall shear failure

Soil is held vertical in a trench wall by cohesion and internal friction. When a trench is dug in Type C soil — sandy, granular, or previously disturbed fill — those properties may be near zero. The wall shears from the top and slumps inward as a mass. The typical collapse takes 2 seconds or less, faster than a worker can move. The soil mass — which weighs approximately 100 pounds per cubic foot — pins the worker at the legs and hips and simultaneously compresses the chest, preventing breathing.

Surcharge overloading

Excavated soil, equipment, and materials piled within 2 feet of a trench edge increase the lateral pressure on the wall. As the surcharge weight increases, the wall below its midpoint is pushed inward and fails in a wedge failure — the most common trench-collapse pattern. Workers have no warning because the failure propagates at near-soil-shear-wave speed (faster than sound in air).

Dewatering failure

Water saturates soil and dramatically reduces its cohesion. When a trench dewatering pump fails, or when a nearby water main is struck during digging, the trench walls become near-fluid in minutes. The collapse pattern is a flow failure rather than a shear — the soil flows around and under the worker. This pattern produces the deepest burial and the most difficult rescues.

Mechanism descriptions sourced from OSHA technical documentation, NIOSH fatality investigation reports, and NY Workers' Compensation Board case data.

OSHA Standards Most Cited in Trench Collapse Cases

FY2024 federal citation data. A documented violation of any of these standards, where the violation proximately caused the injury, supports a Labor Law 241(6) claim independent of Labor Law 240.

29 CFR 1926.501

Fall Protection

6,307 citations issued nationally in FY2024.

29 CFR 1926.451

Scaffolding

1,873 citations issued nationally in FY2024.

Source: OSHA Construction-Specific Top 5 + Top 10, Fiscal Year 2024.

Recent OSHA Enforcement: Tri-State Trench Collapse Cases

Real OSHA citations against contractors operating in NY, NJ, and the broader tri-state region. Penalty amounts, criminal outcomes, and the federal news releases below are public record.

WSC Group LLC

$50,000 in penalties

39th Street, Sunset Park, Brooklyn, NY · cited 2023-08-15

Worker died in trench collapse while measuring area for formwork in 9-foot-deep excavation for underground parking garage.

  • willful violations: Failed to provide proper trench protection system and safeguards.
OSHA news release

Triumph Construction Corp.

$59,153 in penalties

JFK Airport, Queens, NY · cited 2023

Two workers killed when trapped under collapsed concrete slab during utility line work.

OSHA news release

Sourced from OSHA Region 2 news releases, federal court records, and NYCOSH annual reports. Penalty amounts reflect the cited (not always paid) figure.

OSHA Citations on NY Construction Sites — FY2024

The federal standards below were the most-cited safety violations on construction sites nationwide last fiscal year. When any of these standards is violated on a New York job site and a worker is hurt as a result, the citation history can support a Labor Law 241(6) claim independent of Labor Law 240. Trench Collapse cases routinely involve at least one of these standards.

Rank #1 · 29 CFR 1926.501

Fall Protection - General Requirements

6,763 citations issued in FY2024 · 6,615 on construction sites.

Rank #3 · 29 CFR 1926.1053

Ladders

2,764 citations issued in FY2024 · 2,711 on construction sites.

Rank #7 · 29 CFR 1926.503

Fall Protection Training

2,217 citations issued in FY2024 · 2,171 on construction sites.

Rank #8 · 29 CFR 1926.451

Scaffolding

1,937 citations issued in FY2024.

Rank #9 · 29 CFR 1926.102

Eye and Face Protection

1,912 citations issued in FY2024 · 1,814 on construction sites.

Source: OSHA Top 10 Most-Cited Standards, Fiscal Year 2024 (federal data).

Major NY Construction Unions

Most New York construction workers are covered by one of the locals below. Union membership does not waive your Labor Law 240 rights — and your collective bargaining agreement cannot bargain those rights away. Workers' compensation and a Labor Law 240 lawsuit run on separate tracks; you are entitled to both.

Laborers' International Union of North America (LIUNA)

8 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 6A, Local 66.

International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)

6 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 3, Local 25.

United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners (UBC)

7 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 157, Local 926.

International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE)

5 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 14-14B, Local 15.

International Association of Ironworkers

7 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 40, Local 361.

United Association of Plumbers and Pipefitters (UA)

6 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 1, Local 638.

International Brotherhood of Teamsters

4 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 282, Local 807.

International Association of Sheet Metal Workers

4 active locals on NY job sites — including Local 28, Local 46.

NY Industrial Code Rule 23 — Sections That Drive Liability

New York's Industrial Code Rule 23 (12 NYCRR Part 23) sits on top of OSHA and is frequently stricter. A violation of a specific Rule 23 section that proximately caused the injury supports a Labor Law 241(6) claim independent of Labor Law 240. The following are the sections most often cited in Trench Collapse litigation:

  • 12 NYCRR 23-1.7 — Hazardous openings, slipping hazards, falling hazards, drowning hazards.
  • 12 NYCRR 23-1.15 — Safety railings on elevated work surfaces.
  • 12 NYCRR 23-1.16 — Safety belts, harnesses, lifelines, and fall arrest systems.
  • 12 NYCRR 23-1.21 — Ladders and ladderways: construction, placement, and use.
  • 12 NYCRR 23-5 — Scaffolding (general requirements, planking, footings, guardrails).
  • 12 NYCRR 23-9 — Power-operated equipment, including cranes, hoists, and earth-moving equipment.

Source: NY Codes, Rules and Regulations, Title 12, Part 23 (Industrial Code).

What Damages Cover in Trench Collapse Claims

Damages in a Labor Law 240 case fall into five categories: past and future medical bills, past and future lost earnings, loss of earning capacity, conscious pain-and-suffering, and (in fatal cases) wrongful-death economic loss to the family. The single largest driver is usually future lost earnings — calculated from the worker's pre-accident wage rate, projected to retirement age, and reduced to present value by an economist.

Settlement ranges depend heavily on injury severity, age, union vs. non-union wage rate, and whether the worker can return to construction. Catastrophic injuries — spinal-cord injuries, traumatic brain injuries, amputations — produce the highest verdicts because they eliminate earning capacity entirely. Soft-tissue and orthopedic injuries with full recovery sit at the low end of the range. Every case turns on the medical record and the economist's wage projection.

Injured in a Trench Collapse?

Tell us what happened and get a free, confidential case review.

Get a Free Case Review

Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — no obligation.

Prefer to call? (914) 407-3717
24/7 Free Consultation
No Fee Unless You Win. Clients may be responsible for costs and expenses.

This page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case is unique. For advice about your specific case, please consult with a qualified attorney. This website is operated by NY Construction Advocate. This is attorney advertising.

Call NowText usFree Case Review