
New York Labor Law 240:
The Scaffold Law
Labor Law 240 is one of the most powerful worker protection laws in America. Owners and contractors can be liable without proof of their negligence when a safety-device violation was a proximate cause of an elevation-related injury.
What is Labor Law 240?
New York Labor Law Section 240(1), commonly known as the "Scaffold Law," is a statute that has protected construction workers in New York since 1885. It requires that property owners and general contractors provide proper safety equipment for workers performing construction, demolition, and repair work at elevated heights. The law was enacted during an era of rapid industrialization when construction deaths were commonplace and workers had virtually no legal recourse against dangerous working conditions.
The statute was revolutionary for its time and remains the strongest worker protection law of its kind in the United States. While other states have modified or eliminated similar protections over the years, New York has maintained Labor Law 240 because construction work remains inherently dangerous, and the policy behind the law—that those who benefit from construction should bear the responsibility for worker safety—remains sound.
"All contractors and owners and their agents... shall furnish or erect, or cause to be furnished or erected for the performance of such labor, scaffolding, hoists, stays, ladders, slings, hangers, blocks, pulleys, braces, irons, ropes, and other devices which shall be so constructed, placed and operated as to give proper protection to a person so employed."
An owner or general contractor can be liable without proof of negligence or notice when a required safety device was missing or inadequate against an elevation-related risk and that violation was a proximate cause of the injury. A fall alone does not establish liability.
The law applies to what are called "gravity-related" hazards. This includes two main scenarios: (1) a worker falling from an elevated height due to inadequate safety equipment, and (2) an object falling from a height and striking a worker due to inadequate securing. Both scenarios involve the force of gravity causing or contributing to the injury, which is why they are covered under this statute. Falls remain the leading cause of death in construction — according to OSHA's fall protection data, they account for more than a third of all construction fatalities nationwide.
History of Labor Law 240
The Scaffold Law was enacted in 1885, during the height of the Industrial Revolution when New York City was experiencing unprecedented construction growth. The Brooklyn Bridge had just been completed two years earlier, skyscrapers were beginning to rise in Manhattan, and construction workers were dying at alarming rates. At the time, workers had virtually no legal protections—the doctrines of contributory negligence, assumption of risk, and the "fellow servant rule" made it nearly impossible for injured workers to recover compensation.
The New York State Legislature recognized that construction workers faced unique dangers and that the common law was failing to protect them. The original law focused specifically on scaffolding because scaffold collapses and falls from scaffolds were the leading causes of construction deaths. Over the decades, courts expanded the law's protection to cover all gravity-related hazards, including falls from ladders, roofs, and other elevated surfaces, as well as injuries from falling objects.
Several landmark court decisions have shaped how Labor Law 240 is applied today. In Zimmer v. Chemung County Performing Arts (1985), the Court of Appeals held that comparative negligence does not apply to Labor Law 240 claims—meaning a worker's own negligence cannot reduce their recovery. This decision cemented the law's status as one of the most protective worker safety statutes in the country.
Despite periodic attempts by business interests to weaken or repeal the law, Labor Law 240 remains in force. The law continues to serve its original purpose: ensuring that property owners and contractors prioritize worker safety and bear the costs when they fail to do so.
Why Labor Law 240 Is So Powerful
Owners and contractors can be liable without proof of their negligence when a required safety device was missing or inadequate and that violation was a proximate cause of your injury.
This is different from ordinary negligence cases where you must prove the defendant breached a duty of care. Under Labor Law 240, the duty requires proper protection; liability depends on a violation that was a proximate cause of the injury.
Once a safety-device violation was a proximate cause, your own negligence does not reduce recovery. Sole proximate cause applies only when no violation caused the injury.
This is crucial because defendants often try to blame injured workers. Under Labor Law 240, the focus is on whether adequate safety equipment was provided—not on whether the worker made mistakes.
Sole proximate cause is fact-dependent and applies only when no safety-device violation was a proximate cause. The statutory one- and two-family dwelling owner exemption is separate.
For this defense to work, the defendant must prove the equipment was adequate and available, the worker knew it was available and was expected to use it, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been injured had they used it (Cahill).
Work Activities Covered by Labor Law 240
The statute specifically lists the types of work that are protected. Courts have interpreted these categories broadly to provide maximum protection for workers. If your work falls into any of these categories, you may have protection under Labor Law 240.
Construction
Building new structures, additions, or improvements to existing buildings. This includes residential homes, commercial buildings, high-rises, bridges, and infrastructure projects.
Demolition
Tearing down or removing all or part of a structure. This includes interior demolition, exterior demolition, and structural dismantling work.
Excavation
Digging foundations, trenches, or other below-grade work. Workers in trenches and excavations are protected when there are elevation differentials.
Repair Work
Fixing, restoring, or maintaining existing structures. This covers a wide range of activities from minor repairs to major structural work.
Alteration
Making changes to existing structures that affect their character or use. Renovation projects typically fall under this category.
Painting
Interior and exterior painting of buildings and structures. Painters working at height are specifically protected under the statute.
Cleaning
Window washing, facade cleaning, and other cleaning work that requires working at elevation. This protection extends to maintenance cleaning operations.
Pointing (Masonry)
Repairing mortar joints in brick or stone structures. This specialized masonry work often requires scaffolding and is explicitly protected.
Gravity-Related Hazards Covered
Labor Law 240 applies to "gravity-related" hazards—situations where the force of gravity causes or contributes to the injury. This includes workers falling from heights AND objects falling onto workers.
Falls from Scaffolding
Includes falls from any type of scaffold - pipe scaffolds, frame scaffolds, suspended scaffolds, rolling scaffolds, and makeshift scaffolding arrangements.
Learn about Falls from ScaffoldingFalls from Ladders
Protection covers falls from extension ladders, step ladders, A-frame ladders, and any ladder used for construction work - even if the ladder was defective or improperly set up.
Learn about Falls from LaddersFalls from Roofs
Workers who fall from roofs during construction, repair, or maintenance are protected. This includes falls through skylights, roof openings, and roof edges.
Learn about Falls from RoofsFalls from Elevated Platforms
Covers aerial lifts, scissor lifts, cherry pickers, boom lifts, and any elevated work platform used in construction.
Learn about Falls from Elevated PlatformsFalling Objects Striking Workers
When tools, materials, debris, or other objects fall and strike a worker below, the law applies. This is often called a 'falling object' case.
Learn about Falling Objects Striking WorkersCollapse of Scaffolding or Hoists
When scaffolding, hoisting equipment, or other safety devices collapse or fail, causing injury, the law provides protection.
Learn about Collapse of Scaffolding or HoistsRoof work is one of the clearest trade-specific applications of the Scaffold Law. If the injured worker was doing roofing, see our guide to roofer construction accident claims and how Labor Law 240 applies to roof edges, skylights, ladders, and fall protection.
Who Can Be Held Liable?
Understanding who can be sued is crucial to maximizing your recovery. Labor Law 240 can impose liability on covered parties without proof of their negligence when a safety-device violation was a proximate cause.
| Party | Liable? | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Property Owners | Liable if a safety-device violation proximately caused injury, even without notice Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work are exempt. Other owners and contractors may face a claim when a required safety device was missing or inadequate and that caused an elevation injury. | |
| General Contractors | Liable when a safety-device violation proximately caused injury The general contractor is responsible for the entire project, including work performed by subcontractors. They cannot avoid liability by delegating safety responsibilities. | |
| Construction Managers | If acting as agent of owner or with supervisory authority Construction managers who have the authority to control safety or supervise the work can be liable under Labor Law 240 when a safety-device violation proximately caused injury. | |
| Lessees | If they contracted for or controlled the work Tenants or lessees who hire contractors to perform work on leased premises can be liable as 'owners' under the statute. | |
| Subcontractors (your employer) | Protected by workers' comp exclusivity You cannot sue your direct employer under Labor Law 240 due to workers' compensation exclusivity. However, you CAN receive workers' comp AND sue other responsible parties. |
Why This Matters
This is why Labor Law 240 claims are so valuable — you can sue the property owner and general contractor directly, avoiding the workers' compensation limitations with your employer. While workers' comp — administered through the NY Workers' Compensation Board — limits you to partial wage replacement and medical bills (no pain and suffering), a Labor Law 240 lawsuit can recover full damages including pain and suffering, which is often the largest component of recovery.
Defenses That Don't Work
Property owners and contractors often try to blame the injured worker. Under Labor Law 240, these commonly attempted defenses typically fail when a safety-device violation was a proximate cause. Understanding why these defenses fail can help you recognize when an insurance company is trying to unfairly deny your claim.
"The worker was careless"
A worker's comparative negligence does not defeat a claim when a Labor Law 240 violation proximately caused the injury. If the worker was the sole proximate cause, the claim fails.
"The worker was experienced and should have known better"
Experience level is irrelevant. A 30-year veteran has the same protection as a first-day worker.
"The worker assumed the risk"
The assumption of risk doctrine does NOT apply to Labor Law 240 cases. Workers do not give up their rights by doing dangerous work.
"The worker violated our safety rules"
A safety-rule violation does not defeat a claim when a Labor Law 240 violation proximately caused the injury. If the worker was the sole proximate cause, the claim fails.
"We didn't know about the hazard"
A covered owner or general contractor need not have known about the hazard, but liability still requires a Labor Law 240 violation that proximately caused the injury.
"We hired a subcontractor to handle safety"
Delegating safety responsibilities to a subcontractor does NOT relieve the owner or general contractor of liability.
"The worker wasn't using the safety equipment properly"
Missing or inadequate safety equipment can support a claim if that statutory violation proximately caused the injury. If the worker's misuse was the sole proximate cause, the claim fails.
"It was an unforeseeable accident"
A covered elevation hazard alone does not establish liability. The worker must show a statutory violation that proximately caused the injury, subject to the sole-proximate-cause defense.
Related New York Labor Laws
Labor Law 240 is part of a broader statutory scheme protecting construction workers in New York. Understanding these related laws helps maximize your potential recovery.
This section requires construction sites to comply with specific Industrial Code safety regulations. Unlike Labor Law 240, it covers a broader range of hazards beyond just gravity-related injuries.
To establish a 241(6) claim, you must identify a specific applicable Industrial Code violation that amounted to negligence and was a proximate cause of injury. Comparative fault DOES apply to 241(6) claims, meaning your recovery can be reduced based on your own negligence.
Read the Labor Law 241(6) Industrial Code guideThis is essentially a codification of common law negligence for construction sites. It requires owners and contractors to provide workers with a reasonably safe place to work.
Unlike Labor Law 240, Section 200 requires proof of negligence—that the defendant knew or should have known of the dangerous condition and failed to correct it. Comparative fault also applies.
Combining Claims for Maximum Recovery
Most construction accident lawsuits include claims under all three Labor Law sections (240, 241(6), and 200) plus common law negligence. This thorough approach ensures that all potential theories of recovery are pursued. Even if one theory fails, others may succeed, maximizing your chances of obtaining full compensation for your injuries.
Case Value Factors
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
Back surgery (single-level fusion)
No typical number
Lost wages, future medical needs, pain and suffering
Back surgery (multi-level fusion)
No typical number
Permanent restrictions, ongoing treatment needs
Multiple fractures
No typical number
Severity, location, residual effects
Traumatic brain injury (mild)
No typical number
Cognitive deficits, personality changes
Traumatic brain injury (moderate-severe)
No typical number
Permanent disability, lifetime care needs
Spinal cord injury (incomplete)
No typical number
Level of injury, remaining function
Spinal cord injury (complete paralysis)
No typical number
Quadriplegia vs paraplegia, life expectancy
Amputation (finger/toe)
No typical number
Which digit, dominant hand
Amputation (hand/foot)
No typical number
Dominant hand, ability to work
Amputation (arm/leg)
No typical number
Above or below joint, prosthetic needs
Wrongful death
No typical number
Age, dependents, earning capacity
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
The Labor Law 240 Claims Process
Understanding what to expect can help you handle your case. Here's a typical timeline for a Labor Law 240 claim.
Initial Consultation & Investigation
Your attorney will review your case, investigate the accident scene, gather evidence, identify responsible parties, and preserve crucial evidence before it disappears. The time varies by case.
Filing the Lawsuit
A Summons and Complaint is filed in court. The defendants are served and must respond. This initiates the formal legal process and preserves your claim within the statute of limitations.
Discovery Phase
Both sides exchange documents, take depositions (sworn testimony), and retain expert witnesses. This is often the longest phase, and timing varies. Your deposition is crucial—proper preparation is essential.
Motion Practice & Summary Judgment
Your attorney may file a motion for summary judgment on the Labor Law 240 claim. If successful, liability is established and the case proceeds only on the issue of damages. Many cases settle at this stage.
Settlement Negotiations or Trial
Most cases settle before trial through negotiations or mediation. If settlement cannot be reached, the case proceeds to trial where a jury will determine liability and damages. Trial length depends on the case.
Official Sources Behind This Page
These government and regulatory references support the construction safety and Labor Law context on this page.
Common Labor Law 240 Accident Pages
Labor Law 240 most often turns on gravity-related hazards. These pages explain the accident-specific safety issues and claim posture.
Related Legal and Safety Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Labor Law 240?
What makes Labor Law 240 unique compared to other states?
What do I need to prove for a Labor Law 240 case?
I'm an undocumented worker. Can I still file a claim?
Can I get Labor Law 240 compensation AND workers' comp?
How long do I have to file a Labor Law 240 claim?
What is the 'sole proximate cause' defense?
What types of safety equipment must be provided?
What if I was working on a residential property?
How do Labor Law 240 and Labor Law 241(6) differ?
What damages can I recover in a Labor Law 240 case?
How long does a Labor Law 240 case take?
This website is operated by NY Construction Advocate, the client intake service for Haddock Law, a New York law practice. If you contact us, your case will be reviewed by our attorneys. If co-counsel is brought in, any fee arrangement will be disclosed in writing. This is attorney advertising.
Do You Have a Labor Law 240 Case?
If you were injured in a gravity-related construction accident in New York, you may have a strong case under Labor Law 240. The consultation is free, and you pay no fee unless we win. Clients may be responsible for costs and expenses. Get a free case evaluation from our team, today.
Resources for Injured Construction Workers
Practical guides for the days and weeks after a construction accident.