Skip to main content

Roofing Accidents in New York — Rights for Injured Roofers

Roofing work happens at the edge. When a fall happens in New York, Labor Law 240 can make the owner and general contractor liable when a required safety device was missing or inadequate.

How Roofers Get Hurt in New York

The work puts you at the edge of buildings — often without adequate guardrails, personal fall arrest systems, or safety nets. Common roofing accidents in New York:

  • Falls from roof edges. Unguarded perimeter edges on commercial and residential buildings. A step too far and there's nothing between you and the ground.
  • Falls through skylight openings. Skylights are a known trap — they look solid until you step on one that isn't. OSHA requires workers to be protected from falling through holes, including skylights (29 CFR 1926.501), and covers must support at least twice the anticipated load (29 CFR 1926.502(i)).
  • Falls through roof openings. Hatch openings, mechanical equipment cutouts, and other unguarded holes in the roof deck.
  • Ladder falls accessing the roof. Ladders that aren't secured, extend the required 3 feet above the landing, or are set at the wrong angle. These accidents can support a 240(1) claim; OSHA's ladder standard is 29 CFR 1926.1053.
  • Roof collapses and structural failures. Old roofs that fail under load, or new construction where the deck isn't properly supported.
  • Heat illness on summer roofing jobs. Less dramatic than a fall but still a serious injury. It is usually a workers' comp matter; OSHA heat guidance cannot supply a 241(6) claim, which needs a specific Industrial Code rule.

OSHA Standards That Protect Roofers

Federal OSHA sets the minimum floor for fall protection on construction sites. The relevant standards for roofing work:

29 CFR 1926.502 — Fall Protection Systems

Sets requirements for guardrail systems (top rail 42 inches high, plus or minus 3 inches), personal fall arrest systems (must limit free fall to 6 feet and arrest force to 1,800 lbs), and safety net systems. Covers over holes, including skylights, must support at least twice the anticipated load and be secured to prevent displacement (1926.502(i)).

29 CFR 1926.501 — Duty to Have Fall Protection

Each employee on a walking/working surface with an unprotected side or edge 6 feet or more above a lower level must be protected. On roofs, that means guardrail systems, safety net systems, personal fall arrest systems, or one of the other combinations the standard allows. It covers holes in the roof deck as well as perimeter edges. OSHA standards are safety context; they cannot supply a 241(6) claim.

NY Industrial Code 12 NYCRR 23 — Roofing-Specific Rules

New York's Industrial Code goes further than OSHA in some areas. For roofing work, the key sections:

  • 23-1.7(b) — Falling hazards. Hazardous openings into which a person may step or fall must be guarded by a substantial cover fastened in place or by a safety railing (23-1.7(b)(1)(i)).
  • 23-1.7(d) — Slipping hazards. Work areas, passageways, and platforms must be kept free of ice, snow, and wet conditions. Wet roofs are a known hazard and the code requires action.
  • 23-1.24 — Work on roofs. Rules for work on roofs, including steep-pitched roofs.
  • 23-1.21 — Ladders and ladderways. Ladders must be maintained free of defects (23-1.21(b)(3)), rest on firm footing (23-1.21(b)(4)(ii)), and in certain uses be held in place by a person or have the top secured against slipping (23-1.21(b)(4)(iv)). A violation of a specific rule like these that amounted to negligence and proximately caused the injury can support a 241(6) claim.
  • Subpart 23-5 — Scaffolding. If scaffolding is used to access or work on a roof, it must meet the requirements of Subpart 23-5.

Labor Law 240 and the Scaffold Law

New York Labor Law § 240(1) is the main protection for injured roofers. The owner and general contractor have a non-delegable duty to provide safety devices that give proper protection against elevation-related risks. If a required device was absent or inadequate and that violation was a proximate cause of your fall, they are liable, and your comparative negligence is not a defense. Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work are exempt.

"Non-delegable" means the owner can't escape liability by saying "my GC was supposed to handle that" or "I hired a roofing subcontractor, it's their problem." The duty belongs to the owner. If the protection wasn't there, the owner can be liable.

The law also covers struck-by-falling-object injuries — not just falls by the worker. If a bundle of shingles or a piece of equipment that was being hoisted or needed to be secured falls and hits you because a required device was absent or inadequate, 240(1) may apply.

One defense you'll hear is that your own conduct, not the missing protection, was the sole proximate cause of your injury — sometimes called the "recalcitrant worker" argument. To win it, the defense has to show that adequate safety devices were available, that you knew they were available and were expected to use them, that you chose for no good reason not to, and that you would not have been injured had you used them.

If a 240(1) violation was a proximate cause of the fall — for example, when the required equipment simply wasn't there — you cannot be the sole proximate cause.

Roofer Injuries: What You Can Recover

Workers' comp pays medical bills and a portion of lost wages. That's the floor, not the ceiling. A Labor Law 240 third-party case can also recover:

  • Full lost wages, not the capped workers' comp amount
  • Pain and suffering — past and future
  • Future medical care, including surgeries not yet performed
  • Loss of consortium for your spouse if the injury is severe
  • Future lost earning capacity if you can't return to roofing

For fatal roofing accidents, the estate's personal representative can bring a wrongful death claim for the family's financial losses, such as lost support and household services. It generally must be commenced within two years after the death (EPTL 5-4.1).

Roofers Union Local 8 and Workplace Rights

Union roofers in New York City work under the United Union of Roofers, Waterproofers and Allied Workers Local 8.

If you're a Local 8 member, contact your union rep immediately after any accident. They can help document the scene, identify witnesses, and connect you with resources. But the Labor Law claim itself is a separate matter from workers' comp and runs through the civil courts — not the union grievance process.

Non-union roofers have exactly the same Labor Law rights. The owner and GC owe the same duty to every worker on site, union card or not.

Common Injuries and What They Mean for Your Case

The injuries roofers suffer in falls are often severe. Common ones:

  • Traumatic brain injury (TBI). From direct impact with the ground or structure. TBI cases require neurological experts and can result in substantial long-term damages for cognitive, behavioral, and functional impairment.
  • Spinal cord injuries. Cervical and lumbar spine fractures from falls. Paraplegia and quadriplegia cases may involve long-term care costs that must be documented.
  • Fractured pelvis, hips, and lower extremities. Serious but often survivable with surgery. Extended recovery means months off work and potential permanent limitations.
  • Internal injuries. Ruptured organs from high falls — often require emergency surgery and intensive care.
  • Death. Fatal falls are far too common in roofing. If your family member was killed in a roofing accident, call us. The Labor Law 240 claim doesn't die with the worker.

Statute of Limitations

A general personal-injury action must be commenced within 3 years under CPLR 214(5). A claim against New York City or another covered public entity generally requires a notice of claim within 90 days, which a court has discretion to extend, and a wrongful-death action generally must be commenced within two years after the death. Don't wait to find out which rules apply to your situation.

Questions from Roofers

I was working on a residential house when I fell — does Labor Law 240 still apply?

Usually, with one important exception. Labor Law 240 covers construction, demolition, and repair work on buildings — residential or commercial. Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work are exempt, whether or not they live there; who hired you does not decide it. On a building with more than two dwelling units, or property used for commercial purposes, the exemption does not apply. Either way, the claim still needs a safety-device violation that was a proximate cause of your fall.

My employer says it was my fault for not tying off. Do I still have a case?

Possibly. Under 240(1), the question isn't just whether you used the equipment — it's whether proper equipment was provided, set up properly, and actually available to you. If there was no anchor point to tie off to, or no harness was provided, the "you should have tied off" defense generally fails. It succeeds only if adequate equipment was available, you knew it was available and were expected to use it, you chose for no good reason not to, and you would not have been hurt if you had used it.

I fell through a skylight I didn't see — is that covered?

Often. OSHA requires protection from falling through holes, including skylights (29 CFR 1926.501), and 12 NYCRR 23-1.7(b)(1)(i) requires hazardous openings to be guarded by a substantial cover fastened in place or by a safety railing. A skylight cover that can't bear weight, or an opening with no cover, is the kind of failure the law addresses; liability still requires that the failure was a proximate cause of the fall. The fact that you didn't see it is not a defense for the owner.

I already filed a workers' comp claim. Can I still sue the owner?

Yes. Workers' comp is against your employer. A Labor Law 240 case is against the owner and general contractor — they're different parties. You can collect workers' comp while the lawsuit is pending. If you win the lawsuit, your employer's workers' comp carrier may have a lien on the recovery under Workers' Compensation Law §29, but that is dealt with in the settlement; it is not a bar to suing.

My co-worker was killed in a roofing accident. What can his family do?

The estate's personal representative can bring a wrongful death claim under EPTL 5-4.1 together with the worker's Labor Law 240 claim. The Labor Law claim doesn't disappear because the worker died. A wrongful-death action generally must be commenced within two years after the death. The family should contact a lawyer promptly to preserve evidence and meet any notice deadlines.

Common Questions from Injured Roofers

I fell off a roof in New York. Do I have a case under 240?+

Possibly. Roof falls are the kind of elevation-related risk Labor Law 240(1) addresses. If you weren't given a harness, lifeline, or guardrail, or if the equipment failed, the owner and GC may be liable when that violation was a proximate cause of your fall. Once both are shown, comparative fault is not a defense. Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work are exempt.

Does Labor Law 240 cover roofers on residential jobs?+

It depends on the owner and the property. The exemption in Labor Law 240 protects owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work. Ownership by an LLC or investor does not decide it alone; courts look at the type of dwelling, whether it was used for residential or commercial purposes, and who directed the work. If the exemption does not apply, the owner may be liable when a safety-device violation was a proximate cause of the injury.

Who is liable when a roofer falls through a skylight or roof opening?+

The property owner and GC may be liable under 240(1) if the skylight or opening was not properly covered or guarded and that failure was a proximate cause of the fall. 12 NYCRR 23-1.7(b)(1)(i) requires hazardous openings to be guarded by a substantial cover fastened in place or by a safety railing, so an unguarded skylight can also support a 241(6) claim when the violation amounted to negligence and proximately caused the injury.

Can a roofer sue if they were told to use the equipment that failed?+

Yes. The owner and GC have a non-delegable duty to provide safety devices that give proper protection. Defective harnesses, rotten rope, and improperly rated anchors can be 240(1) violations even if the roofer was told to use that equipment. If the provided equipment failed and that was a proximate cause of the fall, the instruction to use it is not a defense.

How much is a roof fall case worth in New York?+

There is no typical settlement number. Documented wages and time away from work help assess lost earnings. Case value also depends on injury severity, medical costs, and the liability facts.

Common Accidents in Your Trade

Construction accidents that commonly affect workers in your trade.

Injured on the Job? You Have Rights.

Free consultation. Immigration status does not bar a Labor Law claim.

Call NowText usFree Case Review