Skip to main content

What Affects a Scaffold Fall Case's Value in New York?

Labor Law 240(1) covers elevation hazards when a required safety device was missing or inadequate and that caused the injury. A worker who was the sole proximate cause cannot recover under it. Owners of one- and two-family homes who do not direct the work are exempt.

How Labor Law 240 Applies to Scaffold Falls

New York Labor Law § 240(1) places a non-delegable duty on property owners and contractors to provide proper protection for elevation-related work. Liability requires a violation of that duty that was a proximate cause of the worker's injury. The statute reads in part: owners and contractors "shall furnish or erect, or cause to be furnished or erected for the performance of such labor, scaffolding, hoists, stays, ladders, slings, hangers, blocks, pulleys, braces, irons, ropes, and other devices which shall be so constructed, placed and operated as to give proper protection" to workers.

A collapse or missing railing can be evidence of a statutory violation. The worker must show that inadequate protection for an elevation hazard proximately caused the injury. A worker who was the sole proximate cause cannot recover under § 240(1), and the exemption for owners of one- and two-family homes who do not direct or control the work may apply.

When a statutory violation proximately caused the injury, comparative fault does not reduce recovery under § 240(1). The parties may still dispute whether the statute was violated, what caused the injury, whether an exemption applies, and the extent of the losses.

Case Value Factors by Injury Severity

There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.

Injury TypeIndividual ReviewNotes
Soft tissue, full recoveryNo typical numberNo surgery, returned to work
Fractures requiring surgeryNo typical numberHip, pelvis, femur, vertebral
Multiple fractures / internal injuriesNo typical numberExtended recovery, partial disability
Traumatic brain injuryNo typical numberDepends on severity; see TBI page
Spinal cord injury (partial)No typical numberIncomplete cord lesion, partial function
Spinal cord injury (complete)No typical numberParaplegia / quadriplegia, lifetime care
DeathNo typical numberDepends on age, dependents, earnings

What Labor Law 240 Actually Requires

Section 240(1) covers "erection, demolition, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning or pointing of a building or structure." It doesn't cover every job at every location. The work has to qualify as construction or repair — not routine maintenance of a completed building.

When it does apply, scaffold fact patterns that can support a claim, depending on the evidence, include:

  • Scaffold plank failures or collapses
  • Falls from scaffolding without adequate railings or other fall protection (OSHA's scaffold standard, 29 CFR 1926.451, requires each employee on a scaffold more than 10 feet above a lower level to be protected from falling to that level)
  • Scaffold structures that tip, shift, or collapse due to inadequate bracing
  • Falls through unsecured scaffold openings
  • Injuries from swing stages, suspended scaffolds, and aerial lifts
  • Objects that fall from a scaffold because a required safety device was missing or inadequate

The plaintiff must show the protective device (the scaffold) failed to give "proper protection" — a statutory violation — and that the violation was a proximate cause of the injury.

Factors That Affect Case Value

Height of the Fall

A fall from a low platform and a fall from a high one can both fall under Labor Law 240, but the injuries — and so the damages — are usually different. What matters for value is the injury and its effect on the worker's life and work, not the height alone.

Type of Scaffold and Safety Violations

The Industrial Code's scaffolding rules are in Subpart 23-5. For example, § 23-5.1(j)(1) requires safety railings on the open sides of scaffold platforms, with exceptions that include platforms no more than seven feet high. A violation of a specific, applicable Industrial Code provision can support a 241(6) claim if it amounted to negligence and proximately caused the injury, and it can also be evidence in the 240(1) claim.

The Worker's Age and Earnings

There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.

Whether Summary Judgment Was Obtained

A summary judgment ruling can decide liability before trial. The amount of any settlement still depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the remaining liability facts.

The Defendants' Insurance Coverage

A verdict against an uninsured or underinsured defendant may be uncollectable. A lawyer can identify all potentially liable parties — GC, subcontractors, property owner, construction manager — and verify coverage. Coverage limits vary by project and party.

Common Defenses

Two common defenses in scaffold fall cases under 240(1):

The recalcitrant worker / sole proximate cause defense: Under Cahill v. Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority, 4 N.Y.3d 35 (2004), a worker is the sole proximate cause of the injury — defeating the 240(1) claim — when adequate safety devices were available, the worker knew they were available and was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been injured had they used them. If a statutory violation, such as a defective scaffold, was a cause of the injury, the worker cannot be the sole proximate cause.

Lack of coverage: Defendants sometimes argue the work doesn't qualify under 240(1) — that it was routine maintenance rather than erection, demolition, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning or pointing of a building or structure. The answer depends on the nature of the work being done at the time.

There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This is attorney advertising.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Labor Law 240 apply if the scaffold was provided by my employer?

It can. The duty under Labor Law 240(1) falls on owners and contractors, not just equipment providers. If the scaffold your employer supplied failed to give proper protection and that violation was a proximate cause of your injury, the owner and GC can be liable, unless you were the sole proximate cause or the one- and two-family dwelling owner exemption applies. You generally can't sue your employer in tort (workers' comp is your remedy there), but a third-party claim against the GC and owner doesn't depend on who owned the scaffold.

What if I fell because I was dizzy or had a medical episode?

The question is whether a statutory violation — such as missing guardrails or other required fall protection — was a proximate cause of the injury. If the scaffold and its safety devices were adequate and the fall was caused only by a medical episode, a 240(1) claim may fail. An attorney can review the facts.

How long does a scaffold fall case typically take?

Timing varies with medical recovery, evidence, negotiation, and court schedules. A lawyer can explain the likely steps in your case.

Can I collect if I was working without documentation?

Immigration status does not by itself bar a Labor Law 240 or 241(6) claim. It can, however, be raised as evidence bearing on a claim for future lost wages (Balbuena v. IDR Realty LLC, 6 N.Y.3d 338 (2006)). An attorney can explain how that applies to your case.

Should I accept the first settlement offer?

An early offer may arrive before the full losses and liability facts are documented. Before deciding, it usually makes sense to understand your medical prognosis and future care needs, and to have your lost earnings documented. Review any offer with a lawyer.

Related Accident Types

Learn more about specific construction accidents covered under NY Labor Law.

Get a Free Case Review

Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — no obligation.

Prefer to call? (914) 407-3717
Call NowText usFree Case Review