What Affects a Scaffold Accident Claim
Scaffold falls can cause serious injuries. A claim depends on medical evidence, lost income, the applicable law, and available insurance.
There is no typical value for these cases. What a claim may be worth depends on the injury, the evidence, the available insurance and the venue, and results in other cases do not predict the outcome of yours.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
How Labor Law 240 Affects Liability
In an ordinary negligence case, comparative fault can reduce damages. Labor Law 240 applies differently when a covered elevation hazard and statutory violation proximately caused the injury.
Under Labor Law 240(1), owners and general contractors may be liable for an elevation-related injury when a statutory safety-device violation proximately caused it. The duty is nondelegable. But the claim fails if the worker’s own conduct was the sole proximate cause, for example where adequate safety devices were available, the worker knew they were available and was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been hurt had they been used. Owners of one- and two-family homes who do not direct or control the work are exempt.
When Labor Law 240 applies, ordinary comparative negligence does not reduce recovery. The worker’s own conduct defeats the claim only when it was the sole proximate cause, as described above.
How Injury Type Affects Damages
The type of injury affects the medical evidence, the treatment needed and whether the worker can return to the same job.
NYC construction context: The evidence and coverage must be assessed in each case.
Soft tissue injuries: Treatment, recovery, and lasting limitations affect damages.
Fractures requiring surgery: Healing complications and residual limitations can affect work and daily life.
Knee injuries requiring surgery: Limitations in climbing, kneeling, and walking can affect earning capacity.
Lumbar spine injuries requiring surgery: Surgical outcome, residual pain, and work restrictions matter.
Cervical spine injuries: Neurological deficits and lasting restrictions may affect future needs.
Traumatic brain injury: Medical evidence can document cognitive effects and work limitations.
Severe TBI: Ongoing care needs and inability to return to work may affect damages.
Spinal cord injury: Future medical care, lost earning capacity, and pain and suffering must be proved.
Wrongful death: Compensatory damages are limited to pecuniary losses under EPTL 5-4.3. A survival claim may address conscious pain and suffering.
Hurt on a Construction Site?
Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — free, no obligation.
The Medical Evidence Foundation
Every scaffold accident case is built on a medical foundation. Settlement value's driven first and foremost by the objective medical record. What does the imaging show? What did surgery reveal? What are the treating physicians saying about permanent disability?
After a lawsuit starts, the defense may require the injured worker to be examined by a physician it designates. This is often called an independent medical examination (IME). The examining doctor's report may reach different conclusions than the treating physicians' records.
Treating physicians and defense-designated examiners may disagree in serious scaffold accident cases. Detailed treating records, such as operative reports, post-surgical follow-up notes documenting ongoing symptoms and functional capacity evaluations, generally support a claim better than records that are sparse or contradictory.
Economic Loss: Past and Future Earnings
For high-earning construction workers — journeymen electricians, ironworkers, crane operators, pipefitters — the economic loss component of a scaffold accident case can include past and future lost earnings.
Past and future earnings may matter when an injury prevents a worker from returning to work. Actual records and expert analysis can support the claim.
Economists hired as experts present these calculations in present-value terms, accounting for likely wage growth and the discounting necessary to reflect that you're receiving today what you would've earned over decades. Vocational rehabilitation experts establish the difference between the construction worker's pre-injury earning capacity and post-injury earning capacity in sedentary or lighter-duty occupations. The "wage differential" — the gap between what they could earn before and what they can earn after — can be part of the economic damages in a scaffold case.
What Defense Lawyers Target to Reduce Value
Defense lawyers representing property owners and general contractors pursue several strategies to reduce settlement value. Understanding these helps workers and their families evaluate what their case's really worth.
Pre-existing conditions: If the plaintiff had a prior back injury, a prior knee surgery, a prior TBI, the defense will argue that some portion of the current disability existed before the accident. Medical experts will testify about aggravation versus causation. In New York, a defendant takes the plaintiff as they find them — an aggravation of a pre-existing condition's still compensable. But pre-existing conditions complicate damages quantification and give defense experts ammunition.
Gaps in treatment: If the plaintiff stopped treating for extended periods, defense lawyers argue the injuries weren't as serious as claimed, or that the plaintiff failed to mitigate damages. Consistent, documented medical treatment's important both for the plaintiff's recovery and for the legal case.
Surveillance: Investigators may document activity they believe conflicts with claimed limitations. Accurate medical records matter.
Related Reading
Types of Compensation Available
Frequently Asked Questions
My scaffold accident was clearly the GC's fault. Why might the case be worth less than I expected?▼
I was offered a settlement without a lawyer. Is it fair?▼
How long does it take to settle a scaffold accident case in New York?▼
Why might the insurance company and my lawyer value my scaffold claim differently?▼
My family member was killed in a scaffold accident. What can we recover?▼
Do scaffold accident settlements go to a jury, or are they negotiated?▼
Get a Free Case Review
Find out if you have a claim under New York Labor Law. A licensed NY attorney will review your case and call you back.
