
What Affects a NY Construction Accident Case's Value?
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
The Single Biggest Factor: Labor Law 240
New York Labor Law § 240(1) — known as the Scaffold Law — covers elevation hazards when a required safety device was missing or inadequate and that caused the injury. The worker being the sole proximate cause defeats a §240 claim. Owners of one- and two-family homes who do not direct the work are exempt.
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
Labor Law § 241(6) extends similar protections to safety regulation violations. If a contractor violated a specific provision of the New York Industrial Code (12 NYCRR Part 23) — say, an unguarded hazardous opening under § 23-1.7(b) or a scaffolding requirement in Subpart 23-5 — the owner and general contractor can be liable even if they didn't supervise the work. The worker must show that a specific, applicable Industrial Code provision was violated, that the violation amounted to negligence, and that it proximately caused the injury. Unlike 240(1), the worker's own comparative negligence can reduce a 241(6) recovery.
Case Value Factors by Accident Type
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
| Accident Type | Individual Review | Key Driver |
|---|---|---|
| Scaffold fall (serious injury) | No typical number | Labor Law 240(1) violation and proximate cause |
| Ladder fall | No typical number | Defective equipment, improper setup |
| Falling object | No typical number | 240(1) overhead protection failure |
| Trench collapse | No typical number | 241(6) Industrial Code violation; OSHA violations as evidence of negligence |
| Spinal cord injury (any cause) | No typical number | Lifetime care costs, lost wages |
| Traumatic brain injury | No typical number | Neuropsychological evidence, life care plan |
| Wrongful death | No typical number | Age, earnings, number of dependents |
| Fractures (non-catastrophic) | No typical number | Surgery required, recovery time |
Five Factors That Affect Case Value
1. Injury Severity and Permanence
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
2. Liability Clarity Under Labor Law 240 or 241
If your attorney obtains summary judgment on liability — meaning a judge rules the defendant is liable as a matter of law before trial — the remaining dispute is about damages. That can change settlement discussions, but it does not set an amount.
3. Lost Wages and Earning Capacity
A worker who can't return to the trade may claim lost future earnings. An economist can calculate future earnings based on the worker's documented wages, benefits and work history.
4. Multiple Defendants
Most large NY construction projects have a general contractor, multiple subcontractors, and a property owner — all potentially liable. Each potentially liable party may have separate insurance. Coverage limits vary by project and party. A lawyer can identify available policies, but coverage alone does not determine case value.
5. Medical Costs and Future Care
Past medical bills and the cost of future care are part of the damages case. In serious cases they're usually supported by treating doctors and a life care plan.
Factors That Can Reduce Value
Not every Labor Law case is a slam dunk. A few things that can reduce settlement value:
- Pre-existing conditions: If you had a prior back injury, the defense will argue the current injury was pre-existing. Strong medical documentation of the gap in symptoms — or expert testimony distinguishing the new trauma — is essential.
- Recalcitrant worker / sole proximate cause: Under Cahill v. Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority, 4 N.Y.3d 35 (2004), a worker can be the sole proximate cause of the injury — defeating a 240(1) claim — when adequate safety devices were available, the worker knew they were available and was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been injured had they used them.
- No Labor Law coverage: Labor Law 240(1) applies to the erection, demolition, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning or pointing of a building or structure. It doesn't cover routine maintenance. If your accident happened during routine maintenance rather than covered work, 240(1) does not apply.
- Limited insurance: A judgment against a judgment-proof defendant is worth nothing. We investigate insurance coverage early.
How Insurance Companies Value Construction Cases
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
Experienced construction injury attorneys know this. The strategy is: establish liability through discovery and, when possible, summary judgment; build the damages case through medical experts, life care planners, and economists; then negotiate from strength. The final amount depends on the evidence and negotiations.
Verdict vs. Settlement: Which Is Better?
Many construction injury cases settle before trial. Trials are expensive, slow, and uncertain even with strong liability evidence. Whether to settle or try a case depends on the evidence, the offer, and the client's goals.
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
Statute of Limitations
You have three years from the date of injury to file a personal injury lawsuit in New York (CPLR § 214). Wrongful death claims have two years from the date of death (EPTL § 5-4.1). If a city or other municipal entity is involved, a Notice of Claim generally must be served within 90 days under General Municipal Law § 50-e; a court may, in its discretion, extend that time on application. A lawsuit against a city, county, town, village, fire district or school district generally must be started within one year and 90 days after the accident (General Municipal Law § 50-i). The same 90-day notice and one-year-and-90-day suit deadline apply to the MTA (Public Authorities Law § 1276). The Port Authority has its own notice statute, and claims against the State must be filed, or a notice of intention served, within 90 days (Court of Claims Act § 10(3)). Missing a deadline can bar the claim.
Don't wait. Evidence disappears, witnesses move on, and safety violations get remediated. The earlier you contact an attorney, the better the evidence preservation.
Guides by Case Type
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This is attorney advertising.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a construction accident settlement take in New York?
Timing varies with medical recovery, evidence, negotiation, and court schedules. A lawyer can explain the likely steps in your case.
Do I have to pay taxes on a construction accident settlement?
Generally no. Compensatory damages for physical injuries — medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering — are not taxable under IRC § 104. Punitive damages, if any, are taxable. Interest on a judgment is taxable. Workers' compensation payments already made to you may affect the final amount through a lien, but they don't create a tax issue on the personal injury recovery itself.
Can I still sue if workers' comp covered my initial treatment?
Yes. Workers' compensation and a personal injury lawsuit are separate. You can collect workers' comp benefits and pursue a third-party construction injury claim simultaneously. The workers' comp carrier will assert a lien against your personal injury recovery — they want to be reimbursed for what they paid — and any net recovery depends on the facts, the lien, fees, and the outcome of the lawsuit.
What if my employer was also negligent?
In New York, workers' compensation is generally your exclusive remedy against your direct employer for a workplace injury. You can't sue your employer in tort for negligence. But you can — and should — sue the general contractor, property owner, and any other third parties on the project. Those third-party claims are where Labor Law 240 and 241 apply.
How is pain and suffering calculated in New York?
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
Related Accident Types
Learn more about specific construction accidents covered under NY Labor Law.
Get a Free Case Review
Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — no obligation.