
Labor Law 240 Settlements in New York
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
How Labor Law 240 Affects a Case
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
New York Labor Law § 240(1) covers certain elevation hazards. A worker must show that the required protection was missing or inadequate, violating the statute, and that the violation proximately caused the injury. Owners and general contractors have a duty they cannot delegate. Comparative fault is not a defense when those requirements are met, but a worker who was the sole proximate cause cannot recover under § 240(1). The exemption for owners of one- and two-family homes who do not direct or control the work may also apply.
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
Standard Negligence vs. Labor Law 240: A Real Comparison
| Factor | Standard Negligence | Labor Law 240(1) |
|---|---|---|
| What the plaintiff must prove | The defendant's carelessness caused the injury | A statutory violation (missing or inadequate protection) that proximately caused the injury |
| Comparative fault reduces award | Yes, proportionally | No — not a defense once a violation is a proximate cause; a worker who was the sole proximate cause cannot recover |
| Who is liable | Negligent party only | Owner and GC (non-delegable) |
| Can employer delegate to sub? | Sometimes (with indemnification) | No — non-delegable duty |
| Summary judgment available to plaintiff | Only when no material fact is disputed | Only when no material fact is disputed |
How the Statute Actually Works
Key principles from case law:
- Non-delegable duty: The statute places the duty to furnish proper protection on owners and contractors and their agents. An owner or GC cannot avoid it by handing the work to a subcontractor, though the worker still has to prove a violation that proximately caused the injury.
- Equipment must give proper protection: The test isn't whether some equipment was present — it's whether the device was so constructed, placed and operated as to give proper protection against the elevation-related risk.
- Falling objects: Being struck by something from above is not enough on its own. The object must have fallen because of the absence or inadequacy of a required safety device. (Narducci v. Manhasset Bay Associates, 96 N.Y.2d 259 (2001)).
- Violation plus proximate cause; sole proximate cause defeats the claim: The worker must show a statutory violation that was a proximate cause of the injury. If the worker was the sole proximate cause of their own injury, 240(1) doesn't apply. (Blake v. Neighborhood Housing Services of N.Y. City, 1 N.Y.3d 280 (2003)). If a violation — for example, a defective scaffold — was also a cause, the worker cannot be the sole proximate cause.
The Summary Judgment Inflection Point
Plaintiff's attorneys who practice construction injury law file early motions for summary judgment on liability when the facts support it. This is one of the most important strategic decisions in a 240(1) case.
A summary judgment ruling can decide liability before trial. Medical evidence, lost earnings, costs, and any remaining disputes still matter to settlement discussions.
A summary judgment ruling decides liability on the facts before trial. The amount of any settlement still depends on the injury, lost earnings, medical costs, and remaining issues.
Factors That Affect Case Value
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts.
| Injury / Outcome | Individual Review | Individual Review |
|---|---|---|
| Lumbar/cervical herniation, surgery | No typical number | No typical number |
| Hip or knee replacement (injury-related) | No typical number | No typical number |
| Bilateral lower extremity fractures | No typical number | No typical number |
| Traumatic brain injury (moderate) | No typical number | No typical number |
| Paraplegia | No typical number | No typical number |
| Quadriplegia | No typical number | No typical number |
Verdicts are subject to post-trial motions and appeal, which can reduce them. A settlement ends the case on agreed terms.
Labor Law 241(6) — The Safety Regulation Companion
Labor Law § 241(6) provides a separate but related protection: a claim requires a violation of a specific, applicable provision of the New York Industrial Code (12 NYCRR Part 23) that amounted to negligence and proximately caused the injury. Unlike 240(1), the worker's comparative negligence can reduce a 241(6) recovery. Section 240(1) also requires a statutory violation that proximately caused the injury, but does not require a violation of a specific Industrial Code rule.
But 241(6) covers a broader range of accidents than 240(1) — not just falls. Machinery accidents, trench collapses, chemical exposures, and equipment failures can support 241(6) claims if a specific, applicable Industrial Code section was violated. Industrial Code provisions often raised in these claims:
- § 23-1.7(b): Falling hazards and hazardous openings
- § 23-1.7(e): Tripping hazards
- § 23-2.1(a): Storage of material and equipment
- Subpart 23-5: Scaffolding
- Subpart 23-9: Power-operated equipment
Some accidents support both 240(1) and 241(6) claims. Each claim has its own elements and defenses, and each has to be proved on its own.
Court Decisions Worth Knowing
A few New York Court of Appeals rulings that shape how 240(1) claims are analyzed:
- Wilinski v. 334 East 92nd Housing Development Fund Corp., 18 N.Y.3d 1 (2011): Two metal plumbing pipes, roughly 8 to 10 feet tall, fell onto a worker who was standing on the same floor. The Court rejected the rule that a worker can never recover when struck by a falling object whose base stands at the same level as the worker. What matters is whether the injury flowed from a physically significant elevation differential.
- Blake v. Neighborhood Housing Services of N.Y. City, 1 N.Y.3d 280 (2003): The worker must prove a statutory violation that was a proximate cause of the injury. A worker who was solely to blame for the accident cannot recover under 240(1).
- Cahill v. Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority, 4 N.Y.3d 35 (2004): Comparative negligence is not a defense under 240(1), but a worker can be the sole proximate cause when adequate safety devices were available, the worker knew they were available and was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been injured had they used them.
There is no typical number. Case value depends on injury severity, lost earnings, medical costs, and the liability facts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This is attorney advertising.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Labor Law 240 apply to residential properties?
There's a homeowner exemption. Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work are exempt from 240(1) liability. Hiring a contractor alone does not remove the exemption; the question is whether the homeowner directed or controlled how the work was done. Condos, co-ops, apartments, and commercial buildings don't get the exemption at all.
My employer said it was my fault. Does that affect my 240 claim?
Your employer's opinion about fault doesn't decide a 240(1) claim. If a statutory violation was a proximate cause of the injury, the worker's own comparative negligence is not a defense. The defense that remains is sole proximate cause: for example, the recalcitrant-worker situation, where adequate safety devices were available, the worker knew they were available and was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been injured had they used them. If a statutory violation — such as a defective scaffold — contributed to the fall, the worker cannot be the sole proximate cause.
Can I bring a Labor Law 240 claim against a construction manager who doesn't own the property?
Possibly, if the construction manager had authority to supervise, direct, or control the work. The statute covers "contractors", which courts have interpreted to include construction managers exercising GC-like authority. The key question is whether they had the ability to control the activity that caused the injury, not whether they held the "general contractor" title.
How is pain and suffering valued in Labor Law 240 cases?
There's no fixed formula. A jury decides what is reasonable, and appellate courts can review an award to see whether it deviates materially from what would be reasonable compensation (CPLR 5501(c)).
What's the difference between settling before and after summary judgment?
Before summary judgment, liability may still be disputed. A ruling on liability can narrow the issues in settlement talks, but it does not set an amount. Any offer depends on the evidence of injury and losses, along with issues that remain unresolved.
Related Accident Types
Learn more about specific construction accidents covered under NY Labor Law.
Get a Free Case Review
Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — no obligation.