
New York Labor Law 241(6):
Industrial Code Violations
Labor Law 241(6) lets injured workers seek recovery when a specific, applicable Industrial Code rule was violated, the factfinder finds negligence in the work chain, and the violation was a proximate cause of injury. Comparative fault may reduce recovery.
What is Labor Law 241(6)?
New York Labor Law Section 241(6) requires that construction, excavation, and demolition work areas "be so constructed, shored, equipped, guarded, arranged, operated and conducted as to provide reasonable and adequate protection and safety to the persons employed therein or lawfully frequenting such places." That language — "reasonable and adequate protection" — is the foundation of every 241(6) claim.
But the statute itself is broad. Courts have held that Section 241(6) only creates a viable cause of action when a plaintiff can point to a specific, concrete provision of the New York Industrial Code (12 NYCRR Part 23) that was violated. The Industrial Code contains detailed safety regulations governing everything from scaffold construction to trench depth to hard hat requirements. Identifying the right code section is the critical first step in any 241(6) case.
"All areas in which construction, excavation or demolition work is being performed shall be so constructed, shored, equipped, guarded, arranged, operated and conducted as to provide reasonable and adequate protection and safety to the persons employed therein or lawfully frequenting such places."
The sequence is: specific applicable Industrial Code rule → violation → negligence in the work chain → proximate cause → comparative fault. A violation is some evidence of negligence, not negligence per se. The factfinder must find negligence by a party in the work chain; an owner or general contractor may be liable for that negligence even if it was not their own. OSHA rules cannot supply the §241(6) predicate.
The "Reasonable and Adequate Protection" Standard
Section 241(6) imposes a nondelegable duty on owners and general contractors, but a violation of a concrete Industrial Code rule is only some evidence of negligence. The factfinder must still find negligence in the work chain and proximate cause. Comparative negligence can reduce recovery.
Section 240(1) requires a violation involving a required device that failed to give proper protection against an elevation-related risk, and that violation must be a proximate cause. A fall alone does not establish liability. Once those elements are shown, comparative negligence is not a defense. A worker's conduct defeats the claim only when there was no causative violation and that conduct was the sole proximate cause. When the worker did not use an available device, Cahill asks whether adequate devices were available, the worker knew and was expected to use them, chose without good reason not to, and would have avoided injury by using them. Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work have a separate statutory exemption under both sections.
Key Distinction: Specificity Matters
Not every Industrial Code provision can support a 241(6) claim. The Court of Appeals has repeatedly held that only provisions stating a "specific positive command" — concrete requirements rather than general safety goals — qualify. For instance:
Specific Enough
- 23-1.7(b)(1)(i): hazardous openings require a substantial cover fastened in place or a safety railing
- 23-1.7(d): "Ice, snow, water, grease and any other foreign substance which may cause slippery footing shall be removed, sanded or covered to provide safe footing"
- 23-5.1(b): the footing or anchorage of a ground-supported scaffold "shall be sound, rigid, capable of supporting the maximum load intended to be imposed thereon without settling or deformation"
Too General
- Provisions saying "take reasonable precautions"
- Provisions that merely restate the general duty of care
- Requirements that lack measurable standards
12 NYCRR Part 23: Key Industrial Code Sections
The New York Industrial Code (12 NYCRR Part 23) is titled "Protection In Construction, Demolition And Excavation Operations." Its specific requirements vary by the condition at issue. These selected pinpoints illustrate how facts must fit an exact rule:
Addresses falling material in an area where workers are normally exposed.
Requires a substantial cover fastened in place or a safety railing for a hazardous opening.
Address specified slipping conditions and tripping hazards in passageways or working areas.
Address ladder load capacity, maintenance and defects, and holding or securing a leaning ladder against side slip when work is performed from rungs six feet or more above the footing.
Address footing or anchorage for ground-supported scaffolds and open-side railings, subject to the listed railing exceptions.
Which Industrial Code rule fits the accident?
Match the accident to a specific, applicable rule, then prove its violation, negligence in the work chain, and proximate cause. Comparative fault can reduce a §241(6) recovery.
| Situation | Rule to examine | What still must be proven |
|---|---|---|
| Material falls where workers are normally exposed | 23-1.7(a)(1): overhead protection | Show the work area and exposure fit the rule, the required protection was missing or deficient, work-chain negligence, and proximate cause. |
| Worker steps or falls into a hazardous opening | 23-1.7(b)(1)(i): fastened substantial cover or safety railing | Show the opening was hazardous, the required cover or railing was absent or deficient, work-chain negligence, and proximate cause. |
| Worker slips on ice, snow, water, grease or another foreign substance on a floor, passageway, walkway, scaffold, platform or other elevated working surface, or trips in a passageway or working area | 23-1.7(d) or (e): applicable slipping or tripping requirement | Identify the exact subsection and covered location or condition, then prove violation, work-chain negligence, and proximate cause. |
| Ladder breaks or is defective, or a leaning ladder used for work six feet or more above its footing was not held or secured against side slip | 23-1.21(b)(1), (b)(3), or (b)(4)(iv) | Match the ladder's strength, defect, or securing condition to the exact requirement, then prove violation, work-chain negligence, and proximate cause. |
| Scaffold footing fails or an open side lacks a railing | 23-5.1(b) or (j)(1) | Show deficient footing or anchorage, or an open side without a required railing; then prove work-chain negligence and proximate cause. The railing rule does not apply to platforms no more than seven feet high, needle beam scaffolds, ironworkers' floats and rivet heater platforms, ladder jack scaffolds, or trestle and extension trestle ladder scaffolds. |
How Plaintiffs Prove a 241(6) Claim
The claim follows a sequence: specific applicable rule, violation, negligence in the work chain, and proximate cause. Comparative negligence may then reduce recovery.
1. Identify a specific applicable rule
Name the concrete Industrial Code subsection and show that it applies to the work area and hazard. A general duty such as 23-1.5, a bare 23-1.7 citation, or an OSHA rule cannot supply the §241(6) predicate.
For a hazardous opening, examine 23-1.7(b)(1)(i), including its cover or railing requirement.
2. Prove a violation
Compare the actual condition with that rule's precise requirement. Photographs, measurements, testimony, and inspection records may matter.
For a ladder, identify whether strength, a defect, or holding or securing a leaning ladder under the applicable 23-1.21(b) item is at issue.
3. Establish negligence in the work chain
A code violation is some evidence of negligence, not negligence per se. The factfinder must still find negligence by a party in the work chain; the owner or general contractor can be liable for it even if it was not their own.
Identify the party and conduct connected with the condition rather than assuming the citation decides negligence.
4. Connect the violation to the injury
Show that the violation was a proximate cause of the injury, not merely a condition present at the site.
Match the cited defect to how the accident occurred.
5. Assess comparative fault
The worker's comparative negligence is a defense and may reduce recovery under §241(6).
Consider all conduct that may have contributed to the injury.
Labor Law 240 vs. 241(6): Required Proof
The two statutes require different proof. Each claim must satisfy its own elements and applicable owner exemption.
| Feature | Labor Law 240 | Labor Law 241(6) |
|---|---|---|
| What must be proven | A required device failed to provide proper protection against an elevation-related risk, in violation of §240(1), and that violation was a proximate cause. | A specific applicable Industrial Code rule was violated; that violation is some evidence of work-chain negligence, which the factfinder must find, and it was a proximate cause. |
| Worker fault | Once a violation and proximate cause are shown, comparative negligence does not reduce recovery. Conduct can defeat the claim only when there was no causative violation and it was the sole proximate cause. | Comparative negligence is a defense and can reduce recovery. |
| Separate statutory limit | Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work are exempt. | The same one- and two-family owner exemption must be checked separately. |
For §240(1), an adequate device provided and used in a way that alone caused the accident may support a sole-proximate-cause defense (Blake). If the worker did not use available devices, Cahill requires proof that adequate devices were available, the worker knew and was expected to use them, chose without good reason not to, and would have avoided injury by using them.
Related Accident Types
Explore accident types where a specific Industrial Code subsection may apply to the facts:
Official Sources Behind This Page
These government and regulatory references support the construction safety and Labor Law context on this page.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Labor Law 241(6)?
How is 241(6) different from Labor Law 240(1)?
What Industrial Code rule can support a claim?
Can I bring both §240(1) and §241(6) claims?
Who can be held liable under §241(6)?
Does worker fault matter?
Does an OSHA citation establish a §241(6) claim?
What deadline applies to a §241(6) claim?
This website is operated by NY Construction Advocate, the client intake service for Haddock Law, a New York law practice. If you contact us, your case will be reviewed by our attorneys. If co-counsel is brought in, any fee arrangement will be disclosed in writing. This is attorney advertising.
Were You Injured Due to a Safety Violation?
If a specific applicable Industrial Code violation was a proximate cause of your injury and the factfinder finds negligence in the work chain, you may have a §241(6) claim. The consultation is free, and you pay no fee unless we recover compensation for you. Clients may be responsible for costs and expenses.
Resources for Injured Construction Workers
Practical guides for the days and weeks after a construction accident.