
Third-Party Claims After a Construction Accident — Going Beyond Workers' Comp
Workers' comp doesn't pay for pain and suffering. A third-party claim against the property owner or general contractor can.
What Workers' Comp Actually Covers
Workers' compensation covers two things: your medical bills and a portion of your lost wages (typically two-thirds of your average weekly wage, up to a state cap). That's it. Workers' comp pays nothing for:
- Pain and suffering
- Permanent disability beyond the scheduled amounts
- Your full lost wages (comp replaces about 2/3, capped)
- Future lost earning capacity
- Quality of life impacts
Workers' comp is also a "no fault" system with a trade-off: in exchange for guaranteed benefits, you generally cannot sue your direct employer. But you can sue other parties whose negligence contributed to your injury — and that's where third-party claims come in.
Who You Can Sue: Labor Law § 240 and § 241
New York Labor Law § 240(1) — the "Scaffold Law" — applies to:
- Property owners — the entity that owns the building or land where the work was done
- General contractors — the GC managing the construction project
- Their agents — parties acting on behalf of the owner or GC
Under Labor Law §240(1), an owner or general contractor can be liable when a required safety device was missing or failed to give proper protection against an elevation-related risk and that violation was a proximate cause of the injury. Once both are shown, the worker's own comparative negligence doesn't reduce the recovery. The defense can win only if the worker was the sole proximate cause — when no statutory violation caused the fall, as when adequate devices were available and the worker knew both that they were available and that he or she was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been hurt otherwise (Cahill v. Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth., 4 NY3d 35 (2004)).
Labor Law § 241(6) covers a broader range of construction accidents. §241(6) requires a violation of a specific, applicable Industrial Code provision that amounted to negligence and proximately caused the injury. The duty is non-delegable, and comparative negligence can reduce the recovery. An OSHA violation is evidence of negligence, not a §241(6) predicate. Section § 200 covers general negligence, including premises defects and equipment failures.
Other Potential Defendants
Depending on how the accident happened, you may have claims against parties beyond the owner and GC:
Equipment Manufacturers
If a defective ladder, scaffold, hoist, power tool, or piece of equipment caused your injury, the manufacturer may be liable under product liability law. This is separate from Labor Law.
Equipment Rental Companies
Companies that rent construction equipment have obligations to ensure the equipment is safe and properly maintained. If a rented scaffold or lift malfunctioned, the rental company may share liability.
Other Subcontractors
If a subcontractor other than your employer created the dangerous condition — left a floor opening uncovered, removed a guardrail, spilled oil — that sub may be liable to you.
Architects and Engineers
In limited circumstances, design professionals who exercised supervisory control over the work can be held liable. Labor Law § 240(1) and § 241 exempt licensed architects and engineers who do not direct or control the work for activities other than planning and design.
The Workers' Comp Lien
When you receive workers' comp benefits and then win a third-party lawsuit, your employer's workers' comp carrier has a right to be reimbursed from your lawsuit proceeds. This is called a "workers' comp lien."
Under Workers' Compensation Law § 29, the carrier's lien is limited to the amount they paid in benefits — not the full value of your case. Your attorney can negotiate to reduce the lien amount, and the carrier must share in attorney fees and litigation costs proportionally.
A workers' comp lien does not eliminate your third-party recovery — it just means part of your settlement reimburses the comp carrier. The remaining recovery is yours.
Workers' Comp vs. a Third-Party Lawsuit
Compare what each claim can recover:
| Type of Damages | Workers' Comp | Third-Party Lawsuit |
|---|---|---|
| Medical bills | Yes | Yes |
| Lost wages (partial) | Yes (2/3, capped) | Yes (full amount) |
| Future lost earning capacity | Limited | Yes |
| Pain and suffering | No | Yes |
| Permanent disability | Schedule only | Yes |
| Loss of consortium (spouse) | No | Yes |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I file a third-party claim while also receiving workers' comp?
Yes. You should file both. Continue receiving workers' comp benefits during your recovery while your attorney pursues the third-party lawsuit. The two claims run simultaneously.
I work for a subcontractor. Can I sue the general contractor?
Yes, and this is one of the most common constructions of a Labor Law case. Your employer (the sub) is protected by workers' comp. But the GC and property owner are proper defendants in a § 240 or § 241 claim, even though they didn't directly employ you.
What if the property owner is also my employer?
This is more complex. When an owner is also an employer, the workers' comp bar may prevent a § 240 claim in some circumstances. The analysis is fact-specific — this is exactly the situation that requires an experienced Labor Law attorney.
How do I find out who owns the property where I was injured?
NYC property ownership is public record, searchable through ACRIS (Automated City Register Information System) on the NYC website. Your attorney will also search the DOB permit to identify the owner, GC, and all permitted subs.
If the property is a private homeowner, can I still sue?
Owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work are exempt from Labor Law § 240(1) and § 241(6). This exemption is often litigated and doesn't apply in all situations. An attorney can analyze whether the homeowner exemption applies to your specific case.