
Workers' Comp vs.
Lawsuit
As an injured construction worker in New York, you may be entitled to both workers' compensation AND a Labor Law 240 lawsuit. Understanding the difference is crucial to maximizing your recovery.
Workers' Compensation vs. Third-Party Lawsuit in New York
The Most Important Thing to Know
Workers' comp and a Labor Law 240 lawsuit are NOT mutually exclusive. You can receive workers' comp benefits while also pursuing a lawsuit against the property owner or general contractor.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Benefits
- Quick access to medical care
- Wage replacement benefits
- No need to prove fault
- Available for most workplace injuries
Limitations
- Limited wage replacement (typically 2/3 of wages)
- No pain and suffering damages
- Cannot sue your direct employer
- Benefits are capped by state law
Benefits
- Past and future lost earnings
- Pain and suffering recovery
- Can sue property owners and general contractors
- Comparative negligence doesn't reduce a Labor Law 240(1) recovery
Considerations
- Takes longer than workers' comp
- Must prove case at trial (or negotiate settlement)
- Cannot sue your direct employer
| Category | Workers' Comp | Labor Law 240 Lawsuit |
|---|---|---|
| Who Pays | Your employer's insurance | Property owner/general contractor's insurance |
| Medical Bills | Covered | Recoverable |
| Lost Wages | Partial (2/3 of wages, capped) | Full lost earnings, past and future |
| Pain & Suffering | Not available | Available |
| Proving Fault | Not required | Labor Law 240(1): a safety-device violation that was a proximate cause of the injury |
| Your Negligence | Doesn't matter | Doesn't reduce a Labor Law 240(1) recovery; the claim fails only if you were the sole proximate cause |
| Timeline | Benefits start quickly | Longer; depends on the case |
| Typical Total Value | Depends on the claim | No typical number |
Under Labor Law §240(1), an owner or general contractor can be liable when a required safety device was missing or failed to give proper protection against an elevation-related risk and that violation was a proximate cause of the injury. Once both are shown, the worker's own comparative negligence doesn't reduce the recovery. The defense can win only if the worker was the sole proximate cause — when no statutory violation caused the fall, as when adequate devices were available and the worker knew both that they were available and that he or she was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been hurt otherwise (Cahill v. Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth., 4 NY3d 35 (2004)). Owners of one- and two-family homes who do not direct or control the work are exempt.
The Bottom Line
For construction workers injured in gravity-related accidents in New York, pursuing both workers' compensation and a Labor Law 240 lawsuit is typically the best strategy:
- Workers' comp provides immediate medical coverage and partial wage replacement while your case is pending.
- A Labor Law 240 lawsuit can recover damages workers' comp doesn't pay, including pain and suffering.
- Both can proceed simultaneously, and the workers' comp carrier will typically be reimbursed from the lawsuit recovery (called a "lien").
Understand the Two Claim Tracks
Use these pages to connect workers' compensation questions with the New York Labor Law pages and related support guides.
Maximize Your Recovery
Don't settle for workers' comp alone. Find out if you have a Labor Law 240 case.