If you fell through a skylight or roof opening at work in New York, the opening should have been protected under applicable safety rules. An unguarded opening can support a Labor Law 240(1) claim when a required safety device was missing or inadequate and that violation was a proximate cause of the fall. Get medical care, report the injury, and preserve photos and witness information if you can.
Is it legal to leave a skylight open?
An open skylight is not automatically lawful just because roof work is underway. Under OSHA 29 CFR 1926.501(b)(4)(i), workers on walking or working surfaces must be protected from falling through holes, including skylights, more than six feet above a lower level by a personal fall arrest system, cover, or guardrail around the hole. Section 1926.501(b)(4)(ii) also requires covers to protect workers from stepping into or through holes.
When a cover is used, OSHA 29 CFR 1926.502(i)(2) requires it to support at least twice the weight of workers, equipment, and materials that may be imposed on it at one time; § 1926.502(i)(3) requires it to be secured against accidental displacement.
For a hazardous opening into which a person may step or fall, 12 NYCRR 23-1.7(b)(1)(i) requires a substantial cover fastened in place or a compliant safety railing. Whether the rule applies and whether an alleged violation caused the fall depend on the opening and the worksite facts.
Can't work? Workers' comp and a separate claim
Workers' compensation may pay for medical treatment and part of lost wages after a work injury, without requiring proof that the employer was at fault. A separate claim against an owner, general contractor, or another responsible party may also be possible; for a Labor Law 240(1) claim, you must show a required safety device was absent or inadequate and that the violation was a proximate cause of your injury. Receiving workers' comp does not by itself rule out a third-party claim, but the benefits can affect a later recovery.
Learn more about who may be responsible after a roof fall construction accident.
The Danger Above
Why Roof Work Is So Dangerous
Roofing combines multiple hazard factors:
Height:
Sloped and Unstable Surfaces:
Weather Exposure:
Openings and Edges:
Material Handling:
OSHA's Roof Safety Requirements
Federal OSHA regulations under 29 CFR 1926.501 require specific fall protection for roofing work. These aren't suggestions—they're mandatory safety standards with clear trigger heights and protection methods.
For conventional fall protection systems, OSHA requires guardrails that meet 29 CFR 1926.502(b) specifications. Top rails must be 39 to 45 inches high, with mid-rails at half that height. The system must withstand 200 pounds of force applied within 2 inches of the top edge.
Personal fall arrest systems under 29 CFR 1926.502(d) must have anchorages supporting at least 5,000 pounds per attached worker, or meeting the qualified-person design and safety-factor alternative. The complete system—harness, lanyard, and anchor—must limit maximum arresting force to 1,800 pounds and limit free fall distance to 6 feet.
But New York's Industrial Code Rule 23 often goes further.
New York's Scaffold Requirements
New York's 12 NYCRR 23-5 sets requirements for scaffolds. The applicable rule depends on the type of scaffold and the work being performed.
For metal scaffolds other than mobile types, 12 NYCRR 23-5.3 requires safety railings constructed and installed in compliance with Part 23.
Under 12 NYCRR 23-1.7(b)(1)(i), hazardous openings must be guarded by a substantial cover fastened in place or by a compliant safety railing. Under federal OSHA rules, covers must be color coded or marked ‘HOLE’ or ‘COVER,’ subject to OSHA’s exception.
An OSHA violation may be evidence of negligence, but it cannot supply the specific, applicable Industrial Code violation required for a Labor Law 241(6) claim. An Industrial Code violation is some evidence of negligence; the factfinder must still find that it amounted to negligence and was a proximate cause of the injury, and the worker's own comparative negligence can reduce recovery.
Types of Roof Falls
Falls from the edge:
Falls through openings:
Falls through the roof itself:
Falls from access equipment:
Required Roof Fall Protection
OSHA and New York regulations require fall protection for roof work:
Conventional Fall Protection:
Warning Line Systems:
Personal Fall Arrest Systems:
Hole Covers:
Skylight Protection:
OSHA citations for roof work may involve missing guardrails (29 CFR 1926.501), uncovered openings (29 CFR 1926.502), and inadequate training (29 CFR 1926.503). An inspection file may help identify the conditions at the time of an accident.
A roof-fall claim depends on the safety devices required for the work and whether a statutory violation proximately caused the injury. The worker being the sole proximate cause can defeat a Labor Law 240 claim.
Temporary roof openings are subject to 29 CFR 1926.501(b)(4), which permits personal fall arrest systems, covers, or guardrails for fall-through hazards more than six feet above a lower level.
Labor Law 240 and Roof Falls
New York's Scaffold Law provides critical protection for roof workers:
What makes Labor Law 240 powerful:
Common Labor Law 240 roof scenarios:
For a Labor Law § 240(1) claim, the worker must show that a required safety device was not provided or did not give proper protection against an elevation-related risk and that this violation was a proximate cause of the injury. A fall alone does not establish liability. If a violation was a proximate cause, the worker’s comparative negligence does not defeat the claim; the worker’s conduct defeats it only when there was no violation that was a proximate cause and that conduct was the sole proximate cause.
Factors Affecting Roof-Fall Claims
There is no typical value for these cases. What a claim may be worth depends on the injury, the evidence, the available insurance and the venue, and results in other cases do not predict the outcome of yours.
Labor Law 240 may apply when a required safety device was missing or inadequate and that violation proximately caused a covered elevation injury.
Hurt on a Construction Site?
Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — free, no obligation.
Specific Roof Hazards
Steep-slope roofing:
Low-slope roofing:
Built-up and hot roofing:
Renovation and tear-off:
Metal roofing:
Common Contractor Excuses (And Why They Don't Work)
These defenses depend on the worksite facts, whether a required safety device was missing or inadequate, and whether that violation was a proximate cause of the injury.
"He wasn't wearing his harness properly." If required fall protection was missing or inadequate and that violation was a proximate cause of the injury, the worker’s comparative negligence does not defeat a Labor Law § 240(1) claim. The worker’s conduct defeats the claim only when there was no violation that was a proximate cause and that conduct was the sole proximate cause. If the defense is that the worker did not use available safety devices, adequate devices must have been available, the worker must have known they were available and been expected to use them, chosen for no good reason not to, and avoided injury had they used them.
"We hired a qualified roofing contractor." Hiring a roofing subcontractor does not by itself relieve an owner or general contractor of its nondelegable Labor Law § 240(1) duty. Liability still requires a safety-device violation that was a proximate cause of the injury. The statute exempts owners of one and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work.
"The worker was experienced and should have known better." Experience alone does not decide a Labor Law § 240(1) claim. The worker must show a safety-device violation that was a proximate cause of the injury; once that is shown, comparative negligence does not reduce recovery.
"It was the worker's decision to go on the roof." A worker's decision to access the roof does not itself decide liability. The worker's own conduct defeats a Labor Law § 240(1) claim only if there was no safety-device violation that was a proximate cause of the injury and the worker's conduct was the sole proximate cause. Where the defense is that the worker did not use available safety devices, it applies only if adequate devices were available, the worker knew they were available and was expected to use them, chose for no good reason not to, and would not have been injured had they used them.
"Weather conditions made it unsafe to work." Weather does not itself decide liability. The question remains whether a required safety device was absent or failed to give proper protection against an elevation-related risk and whether that violation was a proximate cause of the injury.
The Role of OSHA Violations
OSHA citations may be evidence about safety conditions, but a citation alone does not prove that a contractor knew about the hazard or establish liability under Labor Law § 240(1).
OSHA publishes inspection and citation records for individual establishments. Open cases and citation entries can change.
Labor Law 241(6): The Specific Regulation Route
While Labor Law 240 covers elevation-related hazards generally, Labor Law 241(6) requires a specific, applicable Industrial Code provision. For roof work, relevant rules and limits include:
12 NYCRR 23-1.7(b)(1)(i): A hazardous opening into which a person may step or fall must be guarded by a substantial cover fastened in place.
The same opening rule: Alternatively, the hazardous opening may be guarded by a safety railing constructed and installed in compliance with Part 23.
12 NYCRR 23-5.1(j)(1): Open sides of scaffold platforms generally require safety railings, subject to the exceptions listed in that rule.
12 NYCRR 23-1.5(c): Requires safety devices, safeguards and equipment in use to be kept sound and operable, and to be repaired, restored or removed from the job site if damaged. Whether a particular subsection is specific enough to support a Labor Law 241(6) claim depends on its wording.
A Labor Law § 241(6) claim requires a violation of a specific, applicable Industrial Code provision. That violation is some evidence of negligence; the factfinder must still find that it amounted to negligence by someone in the construction work chain and was a proximate cause of the injury. An owner or general contractor can be liable for that negligence even if it was not their own. The worker’s comparative negligence is a defense and may reduce recovery.
After a Roof Fall: Protecting Your Rights
If you've fallen from a roof:
Additional steps for roof fall cases:
Insurance Company Tactics
Roof fall cases trigger immediate insurance company response. Expect investigators at the site quickly, often before OSHA arrives. They're not there to help—they're gathering evidence to minimize payouts.
Common tactics include:
Immediate recorded statements: They'll want your version while you're injured and medicated. Politely decline until you've consulted an attorney.
Quick settlement offers: Low initial offers before you know the extent of your injuries. These rarely cover long-term medical needs or lost earning capacity.
Blame-shifting: They'll look for any way to make the accident your fault rather than address missing safety equipment.
Medical surveillance: Insurance doctors who minimize injuries and rush back-to-work clearances.
Delay tactics: Dragging out the process hoping you'll accept less due to financial pressure.
Having legal representation levels this playing field significantly.
The Economics of Roof Safety
Proper roof fall protection — guardrail systems, personal fall arrest equipment and skylight screens — is standard, widely available equipment.
Safety equipment can prevent serious injuries. The cost of an accident to an injured worker and family cannot be reduced to a standard settlement figure.
But contractors often skip protection anyway, gambling that accidents won't happen on their jobs. When they lose that gamble, workers pay with their bodies while property owners and GCs pay with large settlements.
Labor Law 240 forces this economic calculation by making the cost of accidents predictable and substantial.
The Roofer's Burden
Roofing is essential work that makes buildings weathertight and habitable. It's also extraordinarily dangerous, and those dangers are often invisible to people who don't do the work. Property owners benefit from safe, dry buildings; they should bear responsibility for ensuring the workers who create that safety are themselves protected.
Labor Law 240 reflects this reality. When property owners and contractors fail to provide adequate fall protection for roof work, they're liable for the consequences. This isn't just a legal principle—it's a recognition that the profit from construction shouldn't come at the cost of workers' bodies.
Your Life After a Roof Fall
Roof falls often cause permanent, life-altering injuries:
These injuries may prevent you from ever returning to roofing—or to physical work at all. The compensation you receive needs to account for a lifetime of consequences, not just immediate medical bills.
Immigration Status and Labor Law Claims
Undocumented roofers can bring New York Labor Law claims when the facts support them. Immigration status does not by itself remove the protections of Labor Law 240(1) and 241(6).
Undocumented status does not automatically bar a lost-wages claim, but it can be considered when deciding future lost wages. The facts of the work authorization and wage claim matter.
This protection is crucial in roofing, where many workers are immigrants. They shouldn't face additional risks because of documentation concerns.
Choosing the Right Attorney
Roof fall cases require attorneys who understand both the technical aspects of roofing work and the specific requirements of New York Labor Law. Look for:
Before accepting a quick settlement offer, consider getting advice about your injuries, the safety evidence, and the available claims.
The Time Factor
Many New York personal-injury actions must be commenced within three years (CPLR 214(5)). Claims against a city, county, town, village, fire district or school district generally require a notice of claim within 90 days after the claim arises (General Municipal Law § 50-e(1)(a)) and suit within one year and 90 days (General Municipal Law § 50-i(1)). For a negligence claim against the State, Court of Claims Act § 10(3) generally requires a claim or notice of intention within 90 days of accrual; if a timely notice of intention is served, the claim must be filed and served within two years. Courts may allow late notice or a late claim in some cases (General Municipal Law § 50-e(5); Court of Claims Act § 10(6)). Other claims can have different rules. Preserve evidence early: site conditions change, witnesses forget details, and documentation disappears.
The sooner you consult an attorney, the better your case development will be. Evidence gathered immediately after accidents is far more valuable than reconstructions months later.
Your Rights Are Clear
After a New York roof fall, a Labor Law § 240(1) claim depends on proof that a required safety device was absent or failed to give proper protection against an elevation-related risk and that the violation was a proximate cause of the injury. Negligence need not be proved once those elements are shown. A fall alone does not establish liability, and the statute exempts owners of one- and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work.
Related: Brooklyn Ladder Fall: Understanding Your Legal Rights Under New York's Scaffold Law
Related: Accidentes de Andamio en Nueva York — Lo Que Necesita Saber
Related Reading
Primary sources
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue if I fell through a roof while working construction?▼
What safety equipment is required for roof work in NY?▼
How much can I get for a roof fall injury settlement?▼
How long do I have to file a lawsuit for my roof accident?▼
Who can I sue if my employer provided no roof safety equipment?▼
I fell through a skylight at work. Was it legal to leave it open?▼
I fell through a roof opening and can't work. Can I get workers' comp and bring a separate claim?▼
Get a Free Case Review
Find out if you have a claim under New York Labor Law. A licensed NY attorney will review your case and call you back.



