A worker hurt in a personnel hoist or temporary construction elevator accident in New York may have claims against the property owner and general contractor under Labor Law 240(1), which lists hoists among the devices that must give workers proper protection, and Labor Law 241(6), through the Industrial Code's personnel hoist rules. The employer is usually covered by workers' compensation instead.
How do personnel hoist and construction elevator accidents happen?
A personnel hoist is a temporary elevator that carries workers up and down a building while it is under construction. It usually runs on a mast tied to the structure, it is extended as the building rises, and it is taken down once the permanent elevators can take over. Under the NYC Department of Buildings, a temporary hoist is considered construction equipment, not an elevator, Adding or removing mast sections on an existing hoist is its own project scope, and mast additions that raise the hoist to reach more floors are called "jumps." The Industrial Code requires the hoist to be tested before use and after every extension. On many sites these units are informally called buck hoists, a trade term that is also applied to material hoists.
Most serious hoist injuries fall into two groups.
The first is a failure involving the car itself: the car drops or descends out of control, stops violently, or moves while someone is getting on or off. As explained below, how the law treats these accidents depends on what failed. Hoists have safety devices and speed governors meant to stop an uncontrolled descent, and the Industrial Code requires them to be tested. When those devices are not maintained or tested, a mechanical problem can turn into a serious injury for everyone inside.
The second is a fall into the hoistway. Each floor's hoistway entrance has a door that must stay locked or latched except when workers are passing to or from the car, and only the car attendant may open it. If a door is left open, latched improperly or defeated, a worker can step or fall into an open shaft. Even a fall of one or two floors can cause brain injuries, spinal injuries and fractures.
What does New York's Industrial Code require for personnel hoists?
The Industrial Code has a section written specifically for these machines: 12 NYCRR 23-7.2, on temporary personnel hoists. Among its requirements:
A general section, 12 NYCRR 23-7.1, adds that personnel hoisting equipment must be kept in good repair and proper operating condition, with inspections often enough to ensure it (23-7.1(b)). In Wade v Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc. (2013), the First Department held 23-7.1 not specific enough to support a § 241(6) claim, and found 23-7.2 did not apply on that record. A § 241(6) claim therefore usually needs a specific subdivision of 23-7.2, or another specific Industrial Code rule, that fits the facts.
Federal OSHA has parallel rules at 29 CFR 1926.552. For example, hoist doors or gates must have electric contacts that prevent the hoist from moving when a door or gate is open, and the car safeties must be able to stop and hold the car and its rated load at governor tripping speed. OSHA rules are enforced against employers by OSHA; a New York lawsuit usually relies on the state Industrial Code.
How does Labor Law 240(1) apply to a hoist accident?
Labor Law § 240(1) requires owners and contractors on jobs involving the erection, demolition, repair, alteration, painting, cleaning or pointing of a building or structure to furnish scaffolding, hoists, ladders and other devices that give workers proper protection. Courts apply it to elevation-related risks. Hoists are among the devices the statute names, and courts have treated a personnel hoist as one of them; see our Labor Law 240 guide for the statute as a whole.
A fall through an unlatched hoistway door into an open shaft is a classic elevation-related injury. A car that drops or descends out of control can also raise a § 240(1) claim, because the hoist failed to give proper protection against the force of gravity. In Rich v West 31st Street Associates, LLC (2012), the First Department upheld summary judgment for an ironworker riding a personnel hoist that fell freely into the sub-basement, stopping only at the emergency springs at the bottom of the shaft. The court held that the hoist's safety mechanism engaging, and preventing worse injuries, did not defeat the claim, and neither did the worker's inability to identify the specific defect. Where § 240(1) applies and the violation was a proximate cause of the injury, the owner and general contractor are liable, and the worker's own carelessness does not reduce the recovery (Blake v Neighborhood Housing Services of New York City, 2003). If the worker's own conduct was the sole proximate cause, the claim fails.
Courts look harder at injuries from a jolt, a sudden stop or an elevator moving as it was designed to, rather than a fall. In Versace v 1540 Broadway L.P. (2017), the First Department held that a permanent building elevator an elevator mechanic was riding to test his repair was not a § 240(1) safety device. Workers hurt on permanent elevators may still have claims under § 241(6), because the Industrial Code's hoist rules also cover temporary use of permanent elevators (23-7.1(a)). Whether a particular malfunction counts depends on the facts, so these cases often turn on what exactly failed. Our explainer on the falling-worker and falling-object branches of Labor Law 240 covers how courts draw those lines.
Hurt on a Construction Site?
Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — free, no obligation.
How does Labor Law 241(6) apply to a hoist accident?
Labor Law § 241(6) requires owners and contractors to provide reasonable and adequate protection on construction sites, and it is enforced through specific Industrial Code rules. The worker has to identify a specific rule that applied, show it was violated, and show the violation was a proximate cause of the injury.
At least one trial court has found a subdivision of 23-7.2 specific enough. In Montero v Myrtle Ave. Builders, LLC (2014), a state trial court held the testing rule in 23-7.2(m) specific and found it was violated, but denied the worker's motion because it was not established that the missing tests caused the fall. We have not located an Appellate Division decision on whether the door, gate or car-enclosure rules in 23-7.2(d), (e) and (f) are specific enough, so a defendant may argue they are not. For a fall into an open shaft, a claim may also rely on the hazardous-opening rule, 12 NYCRR 23-1.7(b)(1), which requires openings a person could fall through to be covered or railed. A § 241(6) claim rests on negligence, so comparative fault applies under CPLR 1411: the worker's own share of fault reduces the recovery but does not bar it.
Who is responsible in a construction hoist accident claim in New York City?
Several parties may be involved in a single hoist accident:
Your own employer is usually handled through workers' compensation instead, and if the hoist company is your employer, the same is generally true of it. A product claim against a manufacturer is separate from the Labor Law claims; our article on defective ladders and safety gear explains how those claims work. Material hoists, which carry loads instead of people, raise related issues covered in material hoist failures, and our overview of elevator and hoist accidents on construction sites covers the wider picture.
What should a worker do after a hoist accident?
Get medical care first. Then protect your claim while the evidence still exists:
A hoist may be repaired, adjusted or taken down soon after an accident. The Industrial Code requires signed test reports to be kept in a log book at the job site, available to the Department of Labor (23-7.2(m)(5)), so those records are worth preserving. A construction hoist accident attorney can send preservation letters quickly and review whether 23-7.2, § 240(1) or both apply.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. NY Construction Advocate connects injured workers with experienced New York construction accident attorneys.
Primary sources
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Labor Law 240(1) cover injuries inside a construction elevator car?▼
What if I fell into the shaft through an open hoistway door?▼
What if a coworker left the hoistway door open?▼
Can I sue my employer after a hoist accident?▼
Who is allowed to operate a personnel hoist?▼
Does it matter that I was just riding the hoist?▼
Get a Free Case Review
Find out if you have a claim under New York Labor Law. A licensed NY attorney will review your case and call you back.
