A schedule loss of use (SLU) award in New York is a workers' compensation benefit for a permanent loss of use of an arm, leg, hand, foot, finger, toe, eye or hearing. It is evaluated once you reach maximum medical improvement, it is based on a fixed number of weeks for each body part, and you can receive it even if you go back to work.
What is a schedule loss of use award in New York?
An SLU award is a cash benefit for a permanent impairment, not for time missed from work. The Workers' Compensation Board describes it as a cash benefit that pays you for the loss of wage-earning capacity caused by a permanent impairment of a body part. The award comes from the schedule in Workers' Compensation Law § 15(3), which assigns a number of weeks of benefits to each listed body part.
That is different from the weekly checks you get while you are out of work. Those are temporary disability benefits, and they are tied to your lost time. Our article on how long it takes to get workers' comp benefits covers how those payments start.
In Matter of Arias v City of New York (2020), the Appellate Division, Third Department, held that the Board was wrong to bar an SLU award for a worker who had returned to her job at her pre-injury wages, and sent the case back to the Board. The court described the SLU award as compensation for "loss of earning power or capacity" that is "presumed to result as a matter of law."
Which injuries qualify for a schedule loss of use award?
The schedule covers the extremities and the senses. The body parts evaluated for an SLU award include:
Many construction injuries fall on this list: a crushed hand from a power tool, a shoulder torn in a fall from a ladder, a knee damaged when a load swings into a worker, or an eye hit by flying debris. The Board may also award a separate, capped payment under § 15(3)(t) for serious disfigurement of the face or head, and in some cases of the neck, rather than a number of weeks.
Injuries to the back, the neck (cervical spine), the brain and internal organs are not body parts on the schedule. When those injuries are permanent and partial, they are handled as non-schedule permanent partial disability under § 15(3)(w), which is based on loss of wage-earning capacity and has its own limits on the number of weeks paid. A worker with both kinds of injury from the same accident generally receives only one initial award. As the Appellate Division explained in Matter of Gambardella v New York City Transit Authority (2022), an SLU award is available when the worker is not eligible for a non-schedule award at the time of classification, for example because they are back at work at their pre-injury wages.
Hearing loss from years of noise on the job has its own timing rule. Under Workers' Compensation Law § 49-bb, as the Appellate Division explained in Matter of Durkot v Newsday (2017), compensation for occupational hearing loss becomes due three months after the worker is removed from exposure to harmful noise, and using effective ear protection can count as removal.
How many weeks is each body part worth?
Section 15(3) sets the maximum number of weeks for a 100 percent loss of use of each body part:
Hurt on a Construction Site?
Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — free, no obligation.
An award can also be made for a partial loss. The statute allows compensation for a proportionate loss of use, so a 25 percent loss of use of the arm is worth 25 percent of 312 weeks, or 78 weeks. The statute has special rules for fingers and toes: losing more than one segment (phalange) of a digit is treated as losing the whole digit, and losing only the first segment is paid at half. If more than one body part is impaired in the same accident, each one gets its own award, as long as the injuries together do not amount to permanent total disability.
How is a schedule loss of use award calculated?
Three numbers drive the award:
The Board computes your average weekly wage from your total gross earnings, not take-home pay, over the 52 weeks before the injury. Multiply the weeks for the body part by your SLU percentage to get the length of the award. The award equals that number of weeks times your weekly rate.
Two adjustments follow. The Board's guidance says temporary benefits you were already paid are deducted from the SLU award, and in Matter of Robinson v Workmen's Circle Home (2018) the Appellate Division allowed that credit for both temporary total and temporary partial disability payments. Wages your employer kept paying while you were out can also be deducted if the employer files a claim for reimbursement before the award is made, under Workers' Compensation Law § 25(4)(a). Under § 15(4-a), however, if your temporary total disability lasted longer than a set number of weeks for that body part, the extra weeks are added to the length of the award, so those weeks do not reduce what you are owed. That set period is 32 weeks for an arm and 40 weeks for a leg.
Here is how that works in weeks. A worker with a 25 percent loss of use of an arm has a 78-week award. If that worker was totally disabled for 50 weeks while healing, § 15(4-a) adds the 18 weeks beyond the 32-week period for an arm, making the award 96 weeks. The 50 weeks of temporary benefits already paid are then credited against it, which leaves 46 weeks still to be paid. Without § 15(4-a), only 28 weeks would be left.
When do you get an SLU award?
You are evaluated for an SLU award after you have recovered as much as you are going to, which the Board calls maximum medical improvement (MMI). Your doctor has to examine the injured body part, state that you have reached MMI, and give the percentage of permanent loss of use in a report that follows the Board's Permanent Impairment Guidelines.
If the insurer agrees with your doctor's percentage, that number is used. If it disagrees, it can have you examined by its own consultant or independent medical examiner, and a Workers' Compensation Law Judge decides the percentage after reviewing the medical reports. Either side can appeal the decision within 30 days, and the Board's guidance gives the insurer 10 days to pay after the decision is filed. Because the percentage often comes down to a contest between two medical opinions, the quality of your doctor's report matters. Keep every appointment and make sure your doctor follows the Board's guidelines.
Once the award is made, it is paid through your regular workers' compensation checks until it is fully paid. Section 25(1)(b) also lets you ask for it in one lump sum, which you can request at a hearing or in writing to the Board.
How does an SLU award relate to a Labor Law claim?
An SLU award is part of workers' compensation, which is usually your only remedy against your own employer. It does not stop a separate lawsuit against the property owner, general contractor or other parties under Labor Law 240(1), or under Labor Law 241(6), which requires proof that a specific Industrial Code rule was violated. Those claims can recover damages workers' compensation does not pay, including pain and suffering. See workers' comp vs. a third-party lawsuit.
If that lawsuit succeeds, the workers' compensation insurer generally has a lien on the recovery for the compensation it paid, including an SLU award. Different rules can apply when the injury involved a motor vehicle covered by no-fault insurance. Our article on the workers' comp lien explains how the lien is reduced.
Some of the most serious scheduled injuries also matter for a different reason. Under Workers' Compensation Law § 11, a "grave injury" includes the permanent and total loss of use or amputation of an arm, leg, hand or foot, the loss of multiple fingers, the loss of multiple toes, the loss of an index finger, and total and permanent blindness or deafness. When a worker suffers a grave injury, a defendant in the Labor Law case can bring a third-party claim against the employer for contribution or indemnification. An employer can also be brought in without a grave injury if it agreed in a written contract, entered into before the accident, to indemnify that defendant. See the grave injury rule.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. NY Construction Advocate connects injured workers with experienced New York construction accident attorneys.
Primary sources
Frequently Asked Questions
What body parts does a schedule loss of use award cover?▼
Can I get an SLU award if I go back to work?▼
Can I get an SLU award if I also hurt my back?▼
Does a back or neck injury qualify for a schedule loss of use award?▼
Is the money I already received deducted from my SLU award?▼
Can I get my SLU award as a lump sum?▼
Does an SLU award affect a lawsuit against the general contractor?▼
Get a Free Case Review
Find out if you have a claim under New York Labor Law. A licensed NY attorney will review your case and call you back.
