Under New York workers' comp, if your doctor clears you for restricted work after a construction injury, your employer may offer light duty. If it pays less than your old job, workers' comp can make up part of the difference through reduced earnings benefits. Turning down a real job offer that fits your restrictions can cost you your wage benefits, so the details of the offer matter.
What is light duty after a construction injury?
The Workers' Compensation Board describes light duty, sometimes called transitional duty, as work that is less physically or mentally demanding than your regular job. On a construction site that might mean flagging, tool crib or material tracking work, safety paperwork, or a supervisory role that keeps you off ladders and away from heavy lifting.
It starts with your doctor. When your treating provider says you can work with restrictions, such as no lifting over a certain weight, no climbing, no overhead work or limited hours, those restrictions define what kind of job you can take. The Board tells injured workers to communicate their medical restrictions to the employer. Get them in writing, keep a copy, and ask your doctor to update them at each visit. Our guide to seeing a doctor after a construction injury covers what to tell your doctor and why the medical record matters.
The Board's guidance also points out that workers' compensation law does not require your employer to keep your job open for you.
What happens to my benefits if light duty pays less?
You can still collect part of what you lost. The Board's return-to-work guidance says reduced earnings benefits pay up to two-thirds of the difference between your wages before the injury and your wages after it, subject to the state maximum weekly rate, when your disability keeps you from working at your pre-injury level.
Two practical points come with that:
If light duty pays the same as your old job or more, wage benefits generally stop for that period, but your medical care for the injury continues. The Board describes medical care for a work injury as a lifetime benefit.
Can I lose workers' comp if I refuse light duty?
You can, if the offer was real. When an injured worker turns down an actual job offer that fits their medical restrictions, the Board can find that the worker voluntarily withdrew from the labor market and stop wage benefits from that point on. In Matter of Browne v Medford Multicare (2011), the Appellate Division upheld that finding for a worker who refused a specific assignment that matched the restrictions an independent medical examiner had set, even though her own doctor had advised against it. Benefits do not restart on their own after a finding like that. In Matter of Ryan v City of Albany (2022), a worker found to have left the labor market who produced no proof of a job search remained unattached; a worker in that position needs new evidence, such as a documented job search within restrictions, before the Board will revisit the issue.
The offer has to be specific. In Matter of Canela v Sky Chefs, Inc. (2021), the court held that the record supported the Board's finding that a letter describing a "safe work environment" was not an actual offer, because nothing showed a specific position available to the worker within his medical limitations. The worker had not withdrawn from the labor market.
Hurt on a Construction Site?
Tell us what happened. A licensed New York attorney will review your case and call you — free, no obligation.
Refusing because of pain is risky. In Matter of Sanchez v Baldor Specialty Foods Inc. (2024), the court upheld a withdrawal finding where the written offer took the worker's restrictions into account and she testified she would not accept light duty because of persistent pain, even within her restrictions. If the pain is new or worse, see your doctor so your medical record is current before you respond. An updated note does not guarantee the Board will accept a refusal: in Browne, the worker refused on her own doctor's advice and the Board relied on the insurer's examiner instead.
So before you say no, find out exactly what the job is: the duties, the hours, the pay and who will supervise you. Compare it with your written restrictions, show the offer to your doctor, and put your questions to the employer in writing. If the job really is outside your restrictions, say so in writing and explain why.
Do I have to look for work if my employer has no light duty?
If you are partially disabled and not working, generally yes. The Board's guidance says that if you are able to work but cannot return to your job, you must search for work within your restrictions, and it provides Forms C-258 and C-258.1 to track that search.
The Court of Appeals explained the reason in Matter of Zamora v New York Neurologic Associates (2012): a partially disabled worker who is not working has to show that the lost earnings come from the disability and not from something else. A worker can do that by finding alternative work within their limitations or by showing reasonable efforts to find it. In Canela, the Board found that about two dozen online applications, mostly for jobs he was qualified for and that did not obviously conflict with his restrictions, showed attachment, and the court upheld that finding. But the Workers' Compensation Law Judge in Canela had first found the same search inadequate, and in Sanchez the Board rejected a search because many of the jobs applied for required work outside the worker's restrictions. Apply only for jobs within your restrictions, and keep a record of every one.
The Board also offers free vocational rehabilitation help for injured workers with physical disabilities, including help searching and applying for jobs and coordinating training. You can request it by calling (877) 632-4996 or emailing vocrehab@wcb.ny.gov.
The job search requirement changes once you are classified with a permanent partial disability. After a 2017 change to Workers' Compensation Law § 15(3)(w), a worker who is entitled to benefits at the time of classification does not have to keep showing attachment to the labor market. In Matter of O'Donnell v Erie County (2020), however, the Court of Appeals held that the change applies only after classification, so a worker still has to show attachment at the time of classification. The Appellate Division applied that rule in Matter of Delk v Orange & Rockland (2021).
Can my employer fire me for being on workers' comp?
An employer cannot discriminate against you because you filed a workers' compensation claim. If that happens, the Board's guidance says you can file a discrimination complaint on Form DC-120, no later than two years after the action took place. State and federal disability laws can also apply. Our article on retaliation after reporting an injury covers these protections.
Because the law does not require your employer to hold your job, losing your position while you recover is not automatically retaliation. What matters is whether you were treated differently because you filed a claim.
How does light duty affect a Labor Law lawsuit?
Workers' compensation is separate from a lawsuit against the property owner or general contractor, which may be available under Labor Law 240(1) for elevation-related accidents or under Labor Law 241(6) where a specific Industrial Code provision was violated. A successful lawsuit can seek damages workers' comp does not pay, such as pain and suffering and lost earnings beyond what comp replaces, which can matter a great deal if light duty pays far less than skilled construction work. The comp insurer generally has a lien on the recovery for the benefits it paid; see how the workers' comp lien works and workers' comp vs. a third-party lawsuit.
The same records serve both claims. Written restrictions, the details of any light duty offer, your pay stubs and your job search log show what the injury has done to your ability to earn. If the injury is permanent, what comes next depends on the body part. Arm, leg, hand, foot, eye and hearing injuries can lead to a schedule loss of use award, and the Board says temporary benefits already paid are deducted from the total award. Permanent back and spine injuries are non-schedule: a Board judge decides whether you have a permanent partial disability and, if so, sets your loss of wage-earning capacity, which caps how many weeks of benefits can be paid. If the same accident injured both a schedule body part and your spine, the Appellate Division has held you generally receive only one initial award (Matter of Taher v Yiota Taxi, Inc., 2018). Our article on how long it takes to get workers' comp benefits covers the payment schedule while you are out.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. NY Construction Advocate connects injured workers with experienced New York construction accident attorneys.
Primary sources
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to accept light duty after a work injury in New York?▼
What are reduced earnings benefits?▼
Can I get paid for days I miss after returning to light duty?▼
Can I refuse light duty because of pain?▼
What if my doctor and the insurer's doctor disagree about my restrictions?▼
Do I have to search for a job while on workers' comp?▼
Can the Board help me find a job I can do?▼
Get a Free Case Review
Find out if you have a claim under New York Labor Law. A licensed NY attorney will review your case and call you back.
